Advent Symmetries

Advent Symmetries December 15, 2017

Why would God bring the Savior into the world through a female virgin? Anselm offers some answers (Cur Deus Homo, 323-4):

“is extremely appropriate that, just as the sin of mankind and the cause of our damnation originated from a woman, correspondingly the medicine of sin and the cause of salvation should be born of a woman. Moreover, women might lose hope that they have a part in the destiny of the blessed ones, in view of the fact that such great evil proceeded from a woman: in order to prevent this, it is right that an equivalent great good should proceed from a woman, so as to rebuild their hope. Include this, too, in your picture: on the supposition that it was a virgin woman who has been the cause of all the evil besetting the human race, it is all the more appropriate that the woman who is to be the cause of all good should be a virgin. Another thing to include in your picture is this. One may presume that the woman whom God created from a man without a woman was created from someone who was a virgin: on this supposition, it is extremely fitting that the man who is to be created from a woman without a man, should be brought forth by a virgin. For the moment, however, let these considerations suffice with regard to the pictures which may be painted on the subject of how the God-Man ought to be born of a virgin woman.”

One guiding theological principle here is aesthetic: Salvation should stand in symmetrical relation with creation, redemption an fitting inversion of the fall. Another is pastoral: God has so arranged redemptive history as to give assurance to women that Eve’s sin has not left them hopeless.

"I invite you to read a short abstract in English or better to visit my ..."

Can We Trust the Gospels?
"Back to Berkeley, and thence forward again to personalist (Borden Parker) Bowne."

Correlationism and Secondary Qualities
"I wrote a blog post on Patheos about Meillassoux and the speculative realists, but I ..."

Correlationism and Secondary Qualities
"Mike, One of the mistakes that I think we all make is limiting a passage ..."

Chiasm of Five Words

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Cindy Westfall

    Actually, according to Paul and Genesis, our damnation (sin and death) came through Adam, and Adam alone (Rom 5:12; Gen 3:17-19). Women are impacted by Eve’s action: the multiplication of childbirth, pain (maternal mortality) and the subjugation of women to men (Gen 3:16). Therefore, I suggest that the significance of the fact that Jesus is born of a woman without the agency of a male/man is much more to the point (Gen 3:15), not the parallel between the virginity of Adam and the virginity of Mary. Now explore the theological implications that God only needed a woman for the incarnation of the second Adam. And Eve’s sin never left men hopeless. Ever.

  • Gloria Caro

    I also think that it is the most appropriate thing for A Savior to be born from a virgin.