Baptist Taliban Part 2

Baptist Taliban Part 2 June 15, 2012

by Cindy Foster


At first we lived in duplexes right next door to each other.  Then, both families jointly purchased five acres, divided them equally and each built a house on their two and a half acres.
As more children came, naturally there would be conflicts between theirs and ours which produced conflicts between us, their parents.  This was particularly difficult for me because whenever arguments erupted between them (for instance) over toys or other belongings as to what belonged to whom, my sister-in-law would automatically assume the role as head arbitrator.  She was ‘The Pastor’s Wife‘ which gave her a kind of ‘authority’ to be the decision-maker in the matter.  This usually meant that if ownership could not be established, she would keep the item in her possession until it could be.
I hated always being expected to just ‘defer‘ to her judgment when the issues involved both of our children.  It was a constant reminder that I was in subjection to her and as it was, not only in the church but also in our private family relationship.
It might have helped if we had discussed these sensitive kinds of issues between us openly but we never did.  I think it was easier for us to just ‘let it go‘ rather than risk bringing up anything that might cause a huge argument since there had been times  earlier in the relationship where issues such as these had caused some pretty ugly conflicts.  Later, this neglect of establishing agreements and boundaries proved to have a snowball effect that was felt most by my children.  This, I believe, awakened feelings of distrust in me towards her, for I could not believe that her judgement could ever be unbiased.

As time went on we found it increasingly more difficult, being in a subordinate position under our brother-in-law, and to some extent even Paul’s sister acted like our authority.  Not only did Paul and The Preacher/brother-in-law minister together, but they also worked for the same roofing company and eventually worked together in the roofing business my husband established.


They would get annoyed and even downright mad at each other on the job, then since they rarely, if ever, resolved their disputes would have to stuff or dismiss any bad vibes between them to work together at church.
As much as they tried to stuff, dismiss or ignore the tension between them, it still often carried over, or at least,  I could tell it did.  There were at least two occasions where  The Preacher was mad at my husband but my husband was not there so in his absence, he unloaded his angst on me.  Those occasions, for reasons that I can not disclose here, made profound impressions on my feelings about him as a person, and so much more, as a ‘pastor’.

Part 1

Open comments below

Visit her blog at Baptist Taliban and Beyond

Read all posts by Cindy!

Cindy Foster is “Mom” to eight gorgeous, talented, temperamental, noisy, opinionated, alike-but very different kids. She has been married to their daddy, Paul, for 34 years. Cindy blogs at Baptist Taliban and Beyond.

The Spiritual Abuse Survivor Blogs Network

NLQ Recommended Reading …

Breaking Their Will: Shedding Light on Religious Child Maltreatment‘ by Janet Heimlich

Quivering Daughters‘ by Hillary McFarland

Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement‘ by Kathryn Joyce

"Wait, they're STILL bitching about "new math?" The same "new math" MY parents were complaining ..."

Covid 19 More Ministry Responses and ..."
"Yeah, I'm watching BBC too (on the web at least), because they cover America, as ..."

Covid 19 More Ministry Responses and ..."
""Everyone would have time for God.”Yeah, well that and non-religious blogs, action movies, and over-eating. ..."

Covid 19 More Ministry Responses and ..."
"Sure, agreed. My church was among the very first to close.Unfortunately, with fewer sane people ..."

Covid 19 More Ministry Responses and ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • madame

    Thanks for raising these topics regarding family living very close together. Sometimes it’s painted as “the way it ought to be”, or like the perfect community, but the fact is, for most people it will mean some degree of stuffing feelings, and someone will probably feel like they ought to have the upper hand. Not that this is always going to happen, but it is an issue to consider before buying a house or a property together.
    I’m following your story with interest!

  • Yes! madame, these would be just a few consequences of two families living so closely together. It got so much more complicated as we worked together in ministry. “The ministry dynamic further made them believe themselves to be entitled to an “upper hand” that became more like a religious-leader-dominated monarchy.