Why Eric Jackson Confessed to Raping His Sister

Why Eric Jackson Confessed to Raping His Sister May 20, 2014

by Bruce Gerencser cross posted from his blog The Way Forward

Please read We Believe Their Repentance is Genuine, Pastor Says of Brothers Who Raped Sister, for context.

Scott Brown, one of the elders at Hope Baptist Church in Wake Forest, North Carolina, church home to 2 of the 6 brothers accused of repeatedly raping their sister over an 8 year period, recently shared the reason the Eric Jackson confessed. In a blog post titled Eric Jackson and the Power of the Gospel Brown wrote:

Now, you may have heard that Hope Baptist has two of her members in jail on sex offenses against their sister. The tragic family life of the Jacksons is almost overwhelming. It is a story we will never forget.

But how did this come to light? The reason this story is in the national news right now is because of the power of the gospel. Eric Jackson came to the church, responded to the preaching of the Word of God, recognized that he was a false convert, embraced the true gospel, and was born again. His new heart compelled him want to walk in the light. As a result, he confessed his sin.

He first went to my fellow Hope Baptist pastor, Dan Horn and confessed. We collaborated on the situation and the next day Dan called to report it to the authorities in Elizabeth City. Shortly thereafter Dan went with Eric to the authorities to turn himself in. In that meeting Eric exposed the patterns of evil in his home and his past participation in it. Finally, 18 months later when their investigation was complete, 8 of the 11 family members were indicted by a grand jury and jailed to await trial. The father and the mother, Jon and Nita Jackson are out of jail on bond.

If Jesus had not saved Eric, perhaps the devastating culture of this family could have continued, even to more generations. But the gospel transforms and shines light in dark places. Jesus was the source of light that caused things to be brought into the light, “In Him was life, and the life was the light of men. And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it.” John 1:4-5

Paul speaks of the transforming power of the gospel to the Corinthian church. He mentions that some of them had a horrible past – adultery, homosexuality… He writes to them of the mercies of God in 1 Corinthians 6:9-11:

“Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners will inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you. But you were washed, but you were sanctified, but you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of our God.”

When the gospel has truly been embraced, it makes murderers former murderers. It makes idolaters former idolaters. It even makes child molesters former child molesters who walk in the light. Nothing else has that kind of power. Nothing else can break the patterns of sin that once enslaved those who have been called out of darkness into His marvelous light (1 Peter 2:9)…

Eric Jackson is now 27 years old. This means, depending on which report you believe about when the rape stopped, Jackson was around 15 when the rape started and 23-25 when the rape stopped. Ponder that for a moment. He was a teenager when he started violating his sister and a grown ass man who owned a business when he stopped.

One commenter, on my other post on this sordid story, suggests that the brothers were so corrupted by their parents that they didn’t know raping their sister, age 4 1/2 when it started and 12-14 when it stopped, was wrong. The only proof of this claim is a subjective comment the local sheriff made in an interview. There is no proof that the brothers were so under the influence of their parents that they were powerless to stop raping their sister or didn’t know that it was wrong.

Now we have Scott Brown saying that Eric, the oldest of the molesters, did not know that raping his sister was morally wrong. It wasn’t until Brown, using the mighty power of the Word of God, showed Eric that he was a false Christian, that Eric began to see that raping his sister was wrong. Until the moment that Eric gloriously embraced the gospel of John Calvin, he had no clue that sexually molesting a child was immoral. Until the Calvinistic Holy Spirit gave life to Eric’s dead, darkened, depraved, heart, he did not know that what he had his brothers did was wrong.

Those of us who are familiar with fundamentalist Calvinism have heard similar stories. Many of the “new” converts in Calvinistic churches are actually people who were already professing Christians. They were just the “wrong” kind of Christian. Calvinistic pastors are noted for their ability to persuade Christians that their non-doctrines of grace salvation is false. What better way to understand Eric Jackson’s sin and confession than to paint it as a Saul on the Road to Damascus conversion story?

Brown, of course, is an opportunist, and he is using Eric Jackson’s story to promote fundamentalist Calvinism. He even goes so far to suggest “If Jesus had not saved Eric, perhaps the devastating culture of this family could have continued, even to more generations.” If it is the Calvinistic gospel that made the difference, and so far Eric is the only Christian brother to get really, really, really saved, aren’t the rest of the brothers still rapists dead in trespasses and sin? Besides, at least two of the brothers regularly attended Hope Baptist Church. Surely they heard preaching against raping your sister? Surely they heard preaching against sexual immorality? If they heard, are they not accountable?

Calvinists love to make much of Romans 1,2 and the law of God that is written on the heart of every human. Surely, that law would tell Eric Jackson and his brothers that raping their sister is wrong? If atheists know that the raping a child is morally wrong, shouldn’t people raised in church, raised in the teachings of the Bible, even if they are not a Christian, know that they shouldn’t sexually molest children?

Brown’s blog post is quite “Biblical”, typical Calvinistic drivel. People like Brown are convinced that anyone who is not like them, a regenerated sinner brought into the glorious light by the Calvinistic gospel, are dead in trespasses and sin. We are vile, wicked, enemies of God. It is a wonder that all of us don’t rape our siblings and children. We are helpless, in bondage to sin and Satan. Or so the Scott Brown’s of the world would have us to believe.

This story continues to sicken me and Brown’s opportunism and explanation only makes it worse. While I am sure that there was tremendous dysfunction in the Jackson home, this does not excuse the brothers for raping their little sister. I don’t believe for a moment that none of them knew what they were doing was wrong. Unless they were raised as feral animals, they had to know that what they were doing is wrong. Especially by the time the brothers became adults.

All that matters now is that girl the brothers abused get the help she needs. There are also two other children to consider. Brown says there are 11 people in the Jackson family. The parents, the six brothers who are in jail, and the girl who was molested. This leaves two other children. Nothing has been reported about them, their age or sex.

I hope in the coming days that investigative reporters will focus on the patriarchy and hierarchical authority structures found in the Jackson home and churches like Hope Baptist Church. This movement deserves to be thoroughly investigated. I am convinced that once this happens, others will be less likely to be sucked into their pernicious, soul killing, damaging beliefs. We now know, thanks to Doug Phillips’ sex scandal and Bill Gothard’s sex scandal, that these beliefs can and do lead to gross manipulation and abuse of others. These kind of churches give the appearance of being safe places for families and children. In some cases, they are anything but. Underneath the manipulation and abuse is a Bible that is used by men to control others.

HT: Spiritual Sounding Board

Spiritual Abuse Survivor Blogs Network member, Bruce Gerencser blogs at The Way Forward.

Bruce Gerencser spent 25 years pastoring Independent Fundamental Baptist, Southern Baptist, and Christian Union churches in Ohio, Michigan, and Texas. Bruce attended Midwestern Baptist College in Pontiac, Michigan. He is a writer and operates The Way Forward blog. Bruce lives in NW Ohio with his wife of 35 years. They have 6 children, and nine grandchildren.

Comments open below

NLQ Recommended Reading …

Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement by Kathryn Joyce

13:24 – A Story of Faith and Obsession by M Dolon Hickmon

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • SAO

    I suspect the “Calvinist drivel” was what caused Jackson to confess. He committed a heinous crime, he’s going to jail (I hope), but he has a chance to be redeemed, saved, according to that church.

    My bet is that he did know his actions were wrong, but teen boys will often do what they kind of know is wrong under the cover of someone else authorizing it or doing it, too.

  • Trollface McGee

    This makes me sick. A horrific situation of abuse and neglect that was enabled by the patriarchal and isolationist drivel from this church and only brought to light because one of the young men started to question whether it was wrong and they use this as an opportunity to gay bash.
    The crime (and I refuse to use the word ‘sin’ because it trivialises the situation) was sexual abuse. The problem is, normal people see the abuse as being the problem, while this church sees the problem as the sexual part.

  • Mel

    Two things have struck me about this sick situation:
    1. I’ve been a teacher for nearly 10 years of teenage boys. I’ve never met a teenage boy who finds prepubescent girls sexually attractive. To have six young men in a family abusing a young girl in their family makes me wonder what abuse the men endured in their younger years. This doesn’t excuse or mitigate the abuse; the brothers will and should serve extensive time in prison. But something is seriously f@#$ed up in that home and has been for a long time…..

    2. Priests in my church are allowed to use stories from their ministry in homilies. They have to remove any and all details that could connect the story to the family or ask permission of the family. So, usually, we don’t hear many stories about their career – or the story is so general that it describes something just about every adult in the church has experienced. What makes Scott Brown ok with just blurting pastoral information from the pulpit? Does he have no sense of ethics?

  • Jegus, had I known just how long it was going on, I wouldn’t have given so much benefit of the doubt. I need to pay more attention :/

  • My take is, as a man who was once a Baptist preacher and a Calvinist with beliefs similar to Brown’s, that noted conversions are like notches on a gun slinger’s gun grip. What better may to “advertise” the product you are selling, a Calvinistic gospel that turns Christians into to false Christians into real Christians, than having a noted person get saved.

    It would be one thing if Brown wrote about Eric years later in his memoir, but he is an opportunist who is using this to promote his theological brand and to cover up the fact that he had Christian child molesting grown men as members of his church.

  • Mel

    Ok, that makes more sense. Thank you for clarifying.

  • Independent Thinker

    Here we go again. Sympathize with the attacker and no love and support for the victim.

  • Nea


  • gimpi1

    I have to wonder, where did the teenage boys get the idea to do this? Did their father tell them to? Was this a ‘father-led’ home where questioning Daddy gets you knocked for a goal? Did the father partake in it? What about the mother? Was she involved, or just brainwashed to submit to whatever her husband wanted? Did this go on so long out of a desire to “preserve their witness” by covering up crimes? Did anyone else in the church know?

    It appears to me that this kind of situation is an outgrowth of extreme patriarchal dogma. It’s not the first time it’s cropped up, and, sadly, it won’t be the last.

    Oh, and it has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with a loving, consensual gay relationship. Nice attempt at diversion, there, but I’m pretty-sure no one’s buying it.

  • Katharina Bucher

    They very likely never thought about whether it was “right” or “wrong” – they just felt entitled to use her in any way they sought fit. They’ve had this message drilled into them all their lives, that women are there to support them and be their helpmeets and that they can’t help their urges or do anything to stop them. This is a culture that can only breed abuse like this.

  • Katharina Bucher

    Mel, I was raped repeatedly by a teenage boy starting when I was 11 and ending not until I was 14. Nobody’s suggesting that all teenage boys find underdeveloped prepubescent girls attractive, but some certainly do as evidenced by the numerous rape and abuse and incest cases.

  • Nightshade

    Were they taught that all sins are the same, no sin is worse than another, so they didn’t learn that there is a difference between raping your sister and stealing a piece of penny candy at the corner store? I can’t help thinking they had to know it was wrong, but did they understand just HOW wrong it was? Did they grow up believing that men/boys were entitled to take what they wanted from women/girls? Especially the younger ones who might have just followed in the footsteps of their older brothers.

    That does not excuse them if it is the case, and it does nothing to help the poor girl (who deserves all the help/love/understanding she can get), but it may help assign more/most of the blame on the parents who presumably at least allowed it to go on.

  • Jewel

    A few points/questions:

    1. Of course, it was just a matter of time before they tried to turn this horrific story of abuse into a “beautiful”, “Christian” conversion story. Puke.

    2. I thought Calvinism taught predestination, not so much repentance and salvation, but my knowledge is limited there.

    3. It is hard to believe the boys didn’t know it was wrong at all. One thing it kind of made me think of at first was that story Flowers in the Attic, remember where the kids are locked in the attic for their whole lives and the oldest brother and sister fall in love and have sex? You can kind of see where extreme isolation and deprivation from all other sources and people could lead to that. But six brothers with a very young sister is a different story. I don’t know…