What Would America Look Like if it Were Truly… ‘Christian’

What Would America Look Like if it Were Truly… ‘Christian’ March 9, 2016

CindyFosterby Cindy Foster cross posted from her blog Finding Fundamental

This season’s political climate and campaign have provoked me to revisit some of my formerly-held beliefs that America, it’s foundation, founders and founding documents, is positively, expressly ‘Christian’ in identity and purpose.

As one who now feels freer to question former beliefs, I have concluded that this nation is NOT and was never intended to be Christian in identity, though certainly morals and principles drawn from the Bible have INFLUENCED its identity, purpose and governance.

There is a difference in being influenced by and being founded upon.

The first is about recognition and acknowledgment.  The latter is about entitlement.

Many conservative Christians fervently believe America’s heritage to be of the ‘Judeo-Christian’ tradition. Those who believe this to be fact also expect this Judeo-Christian tradition to be by right of establishment and thus should be reflected in its laws and governance.

So, what does this term‘Judeo-Christian even mean?

Judeo-Christian values are somewhat dubiously defined as those values, ethics, principles etc. that Judaism and Christianity have in common. It was made popular by conservatives to describe their political ideals.

From Wikipedia:

The present meaning of “Judeo-Christian” regarding ethics first appeared in print in an book review by the English writer George Orwell in 1939, with the phrase “the Judaeo-Christian scheme of morals.”[5] The term gained currency in the 1940s, promoted by groups which evolved into the National Conference of Christians and Jews. They intended to fight antisemitism by using a more inclusive idea of values.[6][7] By 1952 Dwight Eisenhower looked to the Founding Fathers of 1776 to say:
“all men are endowed by their Creator.” In other words, our form of government has no sense unless it is founded in a deeply felt religious faith, and I don’t care what it is. With us of course it is the Judeo-Christian concept, but it must be a religion with all men created equal.[8]

Conversely there are Orthodox Jewish leaders who would argue against Judaism and Christianity having much of anything in common as expressed in this article by Jewish journalist Yori Yanover: http://www.jewishpress.com/blogs/yoris-news-clips/theres-no-such-thing-as-judeo-christian-values/2013/12/26/.

His contention, simply put, is that Judaism rejects Christianity and Christianity rejects Judaism.

However, those who use that term to mean that America was founded on the same moral principals included in both Old and New Testaments of the Bible should consider if this description, ‘Judaeo-Christian’ is really an accurate term to apply to this country’s founding history and purpose.

For a pretty good overview of several uses of the term:


But enough of that.

What I’d really like to explore here is what America as an authentically ‘Christian’ nation should look like in actuality.

In using the term ‘Christian’, I am speaking of those attributes and teachings of Christ as a believer in his deity or even as mere follower of his teachings.

Perhaps a better identity for Christians of America to seek should be a nation full of Christian people.

Here are some thoughts:

If America were a nation of Christian people in Christianity’s purest sense, its governing authorities certainly would not desire to convert personal moral beliefs and principles causing no harm to another’s right to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness, into Old Testament-derived laws to be enforced with their accompanying brutal and archaic penalties.

America as a nation of truly ‘Christian’ people would not express such in her governance, but in the people identifying as Christian actually BEING Christ-like.

America as a nation of truly Christian people would love their God enough to love their neighbors as their God commands.

They would love their God enough to love their enemies instead of hating them, blessing them that curse, doing good to them that hate, praying for them that despitefully use and persecute.

They would not be obsessed with storing up treasures on this earth.

They would not be slaves to money.

They would do unto others as they would have others do to them–Golden Rule.

They would practice justice, mercy and faithfulness.

They would walk in love, joy, peace, long suffering, gentleness, goodness, faith and meekness.

They would practice unconditional love and acceptance toward those with whom they disagree….even the LGBTQ, Atheist, Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu, and Liberal Democrat, etc.

They would rather be defrauded than take a brother to court (when not involving a crime).

Their love would be patient, kind, not envious or boastful, arrogant or rude.

They would not insist on their own way, not be irritable or resentful.

They would not rejoice at wrongdoing, but rejoice in the truth.

Their love would bear all things, believe all things and endure all things.

Their godliness would be defined by and coupled with contentment.

They would not do anything that would cause another to stumble.

And, finally, America, if it were truly a nation of people who identified with purely ‘Christian’ ideals would not seek to be identified as such, but concern themselves with behaving as those who believe they are pilgrims and strangers in this land.

They would behave as ones who truly believe their citizenship is of a homeland– a heavenly country not built by human hands but a city whose designer and builder is God himself.

Those Presidential candidates and leaders, who have identified themselves as ‘Christian’, who promise to be human saviors of America’s ‘Christian‘ heritage, are largely catering to a disgruntled, disillusioned and uncomfortable group of people who– perhaps subconsciously– desire a morality-policing government that would protect and preserve their perceived right to NOT have to change and/or adapt.

This is the cause, I believe, to be at the heart of the whole ‘return-to-America’s-Judeo-Christian-heritage’ cry.

But, to me, this is a blatant contradiction.

How can one expect to make this country into a heavenly kingdom consistent with the fundamentalist/literalist interpretation of the biblical ideal without using some kind of coercion?

And, how can ‘Christian-nation-by-force’ ever be consistent with the example and teachings of Jesus, the author and finisher or our faith? Hebrews 12:2


Spiritual Abuse Survivor Blogs Network member, Cindy Foster blogs at Finding Fundamental

Cindy Foster is “Mom” to eight gorgeous, talented, temperamental, noisy, opinionated, alike-but very different kids. She has been married to their daddy, Paul, for 36 years.

Stay in touch! Like No Longer Quivering on Facebook:

If this is your first time visiting NLQ please read our Welcome page and our Comment Policy!

Copyright notice: If you use any content from NLQ, including any of our research or Quoting Quiverfull quotes, please give us credit and a link back to this site. All original content is owned by No Longer Quivering and Patheos.com

Read our hate mail at Jerks 4 Jesus

Comments open below

NLQ Recommended Reading …

Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement by Kathryn Joyce

13:24 – A Story of Faith and Obsession by M Dolon Hickmon

"I hope she keeps her behind firmly planted in her rural county. She can celebrate ..."

Nancy Campbell’s Total Dismissal of Covid ..."
"Almost. Those bits Jesus said about loving your neighbor and taking care of the least ..."

Nancy Campbell’s Total Dismissal of Covid ..."
"Best of luck, am glad you have access to good health care! Stay safe/"

Open Thread COVID 19 – What ..."
"Sounds like you know yourself and your medications very well. Hope you feel better very ..."

Open Thread COVID 19 – What ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Abigail Smith

    “They would love their God enough to love their enemies instead of hating them, blessing them that curse, doing good to them that hate, praying for them that despitefully use and persecute.” that’s it in a nutshell…
    I laugh now when I think of all the blogs saying Obama is the Antichrist…until I got out of QF brainwashing, I never knew he was a Christian…he actually acts more like this list than any of these “Christian” leaders….

  • Nea

    Several states had state religions at first. In New England, their Christianity looked like witch hangings, members of competing Christian religions having their ears nailed to posts if not also hung, and all hints of Christmas being banned on penalty of a major fine and maybe jail time.

    It really irritates me when people play “what if” with misty fantasies when the actual historical record is extremely clear.

  • RetroPam

    Beautiful article.

    Some Americans worry that Donald Trump might be a real, full-fledged fascist. The leadership of the party of “Christian values,” on the other hand, is deeply worried that he might be a phony one instead.

  • Cindy Foster

    I sooo agree. I actually wrote an article about that very thing during the election when Obama was running the first time…The slander by the ‘Christian’ right was disgusting and embarrassing.

  • Cindy Foster

    The Puritans who are so celebrated for coming here seeking religious freedom became guilty of the same oppression from which they fled. Ironic….

  • Cindy Foster

    Ha! Well, that’s revealing! I can’t decide if they are that ignorant or that evil….

  • Wookie Monster

    The Puritans were kicked out of England for being a bunch of oppressive A-holes. These are the same people who gave us Oliver Cromwell. The whole idea that they were ever interested in “religious freedom” is a complete myth. All they ever wanted was to set up their own repressive theocracy and when they couldn’t do it in Europe, they came to America.

  • Joyce

    For perspective, my grandfather (1898-1987) was born in Russia and fled to Canada because he was actually truly (in the text book sense) persecuted for his Christian beliefs. (By that I mean, people killed or raped close members of his family; I’m not talking about the clerk at the store saying “happy holidays” instead of “Merry Christmas,” or the fact that he wasn’t allowed to bully the people who didn’t believe in God the same way he did). Anyway . . .

    In the 70s he was very big on Nixon being the anti-Christ, and he wasn’t alone. Others declared it was Kissinger. As a child, I heard this and thought “wow.” But then someone else came along, and THEY were the anti-Christ, and then it was someone else. Quite often it’s the leader of the US. I think its part of the job of president.

    It didn’t take too many rounds of this to realize this was all sorts of silly, and completely lacking in substance.

  • Abigail Smith

    I know…when you read about how they treated others, it’s terrible…t that whole “pesky” Salem Witch Trials debacle (I recently read the NYT Bestseller book called “Witches” and it really helped me to understand what I had gone through being abused in a Puritan church….Yeah, that’s “do unto others”….NOT

  • Abigail Smith

    Can you post a link to your article?

  • Abigail Smith

    Wow…so true…these wackos who are crying “persecution” about coffee cups and Merry Christmas are merely getting what they deserve for acting like fools

  • Cindy Foster

    Never was taught THAT in Christian schools here or even in public school. Although, I am sure my education on this is skewed, I don’t doubt it to be true. Great point!

  • Cindy Foster

    I am reading that right now! It’s terrifying and enlightening. I have it listed in the side-bar of my blog.

  • Wookie Monster

    This country romanticized the Puritans as these quaint “pilgrims” who wore buckles and endured a long journey and a harsh winter. If more Americans knew what oppressive a-holes they really were, Thanksgiving wouldn’t be as much fun.

  • Abigail Smith

    It actually reminded me alot of what’s going on today with these high profile Christians like the Duggars, Gothard, Phillips…no one will admit that they are wrong…and it took the Puritan church until recently to apologize for the Salem witch trials