Answering ‘Preparing To Be A Help Meet’ – Never Alone With A Guy?

Answering ‘Preparing To Be A Help Meet’ – Never Alone With A Guy? May 29, 2016

AnsweringAnother installment of giving better answers to the questions asked at Debi Pearl’s site message board for the book ‘Preparing To Be A Help Meet’. Many young ladies ask questions on all sorts of different subjects brought up by the book. There was just one big problem, many of the answers stray into either the outright bad and emotionally unhealthy to dangerous. Yes, typical Debi Pearl borderline abusive. Here’s what we’re going to be doing here at NLQ. Every week, once or twice a week, I’ll be posting up one of the questions from the message board and ask you, our readers, to answer that poor soul’s question in a way that is logical,  rational and the best possible solution, in other words 180 degree turn from Debi and friends answers. As always all spelling and grammar in the posting is unchanged from the original author.

NEVER alone with a guy, even if just a friend, logical expectation or not?

*If one of the Pearl ladies could give some input, I would be so very appreciative!*
I am two weeks away from being 18, and a month away from transferring colleges — thus moving out of my family’s home for the first time. So very soon I will be my own responsibility, and in order to not loosely wing it when it comes to boundaries, I want to have a clear vision for what is a black and white line I will not cross in order to live rightly. And in order to not get to a point where I may be in a compromising situation where I get tempted to a major boundary line, my parents think it is a good idea to set many precautions in place beforehand, meaning more boundaries, so I never risk getting to that point of temptation. The main point of disagreement is this: I think that if I were dating a guy, or I thought the guy might like me/I like him, or essentially anythinglike that which could cloud my judgement where I might be willing to push boundaries a bit, those are DEFINITELY situations I need accountability with someone to check in and make sure I don’t cross whatever lines I say I won’t cross. I think it is perfectly reasonable to be very careful with the situations and circumstances you put yourself in so that everything will be above reproach. However, I think my parents take this too far. They say I am not allowed, in any setting and for any reason, alone with a guy. For instance, this week I need a ride somewhere 10min away, and I have a neighbor who is going the exact place I am for the same reason (we both volunteer at the local library for children’s summer storytime) and he is a friend I’ve known for over a year that I trust, and has even helped me with a VBS class before. But I am not allowed to catch a ride with him. Because my parent’s say if I am willing to go somewhere that is 10mi away, then what’s the difference with 15mi., or 20mi., or 60mi.? Personally I think if it is a trusted friend, then catching a ride somewhere with a guy shouldn’t be off limits, for really any distance. This is just the latest example. But it doesn’t pertain to just a car ride where it is just a guy and me, my parent’s say it doesn’t matter if we are waking down a street, going grocery shopping, or anything at all, I should not ever be alone with a guy — regardless if we are just good friends or more than that. While I do love my parents and I know that they want only good for me, and I want to respect their wishes and take their advice, this seems totally illogical. It isn’t as if a guy and I are in a place without anyone else (exception being a situation of a car, but still, he is busy driving and we have to get somewhere. We aren’t at a house alone or something of that sort) and we have a relationship where wsoar attracted to eachother. We are in public, which is already some sort of slight accountability, and we are just friends. Just hanging out together or driving someplace seems perfectly innocent and good. If we aren’t attached at the hip and doing things exclusively together all the time, then we really are above-reproach-just-friends who should be able to go catch a movie or carpool. Am I just totally off in thinking that it is okay to occasionally do things like innocently catch a ride or do some activity with a guy friend if we really are just friends? Or are my parents correct that there is 100% no way no how no reason I should be alone with any guy?

Also, this kind of leads into boundary lines of dating. If I am never never allowed to spend time with a guy alone, that just doesn’t like a logical way to date a guy (or court a guy, or whatever you want to call seeing if this is the person you want to marry; please don’t get tripped up with terminology)! I’ve never been in a relationship, but I’ve watched as several of my friends have dated (courted, whatever) and gotten married and been pure the whole time. Yes being accountable to purity is so important and that the best way to really get to know a guy is to hang out with him and his family a lot to see how he treats his parents etc., or him hang out with your family, or social settings in public with friends so there is as little chance as possible to what his true character is like. But I think also doing things as just a couple is good too. But the way my parents have talked makes it seem like there should be no reason for dating, you know whether or not you would marry the person based on friendship alone, and then you golet married without a prolonged engagement — if you know, you know, so get married as soon as possible no reason to wait. I think this is also illogical. Sometimes circumstances simply do not allow for social settings where a group of friends can come out, basically just so you can interact with the guy you have your eye on. The fact that I’m moving away from the town that the only guy I would ever consider seriously for marriage is one problem with that idealic only-in-a-platonic-social-setting, not to mention the friends who would make up that social setting all have lives of their own they are busy with. So how would I spend time with my guy then, according to my parents wishes? Answer: I don’t think I would be able to, unless I am always over at his family’s house or he is over at my house every weekend. And I just can’t picture being able to talk deeply with him about everything important under the sun with my 7 siblings running around — I would want just some “us” time. Whose way of thinking is logical to expect? Mine or my parents? How do they reconcile? I want torespect what my parents want, but I don’t see their way as making sense. So I would really love the input of those who have been or are in relationships/already married and explain what that was like for you, or most preferable anyone who has had children and what were your relationship rules — regarding both solo time if just friends, as I first addressed, and also regarding dating. The reason I would really appreciate it if Debbie Pearl specifically would describe how friendships and also dating looked for her daughters, is because my parents highly respect the Pearls and love No Greater Joy (as do I :) ) and would definitely be value hearing her (or Mike’s) opinion. Part of the reason I am asking these questions on here is because my parents told me to seek out council from many wise people on this so I can make my own wise choices. My parents are all for me being a responsible adult and for me to be wise and make boundaries, but they have one set of boundaries that they think I should set and it is much different than mine.
I hope I’ve made everything clear enough, but I apologize if there is any confusion with something I’ve said; I just typed this entire thing on my tiny phone screen, so please have grace for spelling errors, run on sentences, never ending paragraphs, or any other loopy writing. Feel free to ask questions! I’m an open book, despite my tiny touchscreen :3
Thanks to everyone who can give me some advise on what you think of boundaries with guy friends and dating! :) God bless!

Well that is one big old wall of text to ask if it’s okay to be alone with guys in a platonic way. The answers she was given mostly said some version of do not trust guys and obey your parents. One lady tried to hold up Josh Duggar as an example of good accountability with the opposite sex. We all know how well that worked out. While Josh could not do more than side-hug Anna he was already looking at porn and had molested his sisters. He came to Anna pre-sullied:

What your parents are asking is not so uncommon. Have you ever watched 19 Kids and Counting? Their oldest son, Josh, met, courted and married his sweet wife, Anna – without them ever spending exclusive time alone together. Josh chose to follow his parents’ wise counsel, and they always took along a chaperone with them wherever they went (usually a younger sibling). Their family was wise enough to give them “alone” time in their home – in the living room, for example, while the other kids played outside and the other adults chatted in the next room, or whatever. I believe the Pearls’ did this with all their children as well.

What would you tell this young lady if you could besides avoid Josh Duggar?


Stay in touch! Like No Longer Quivering on Facebook:

If this is your first time visiting NLQ please read our Welcome page and our Comment Policy!

Copyright notice: If you use any content from NLQ, including any of our research or Quoting Quiverfull quotes, please give us credit and a link back to this site. All original content is owned by No Longer Quivering and Patheos.com

Read our hate mail at Jerks 4 Jesus

Comments open below

NLQ Recommended Reading …

Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement by Kathryn Joyce

13:24 – A Story of Faith and Obsession by M Dolon Hickmon


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!