The question of modesty has come up again at Aleteia. In the ensuing discussion, a commenter asked me how someone with a propensity to scrupulosity can “err on the side of mercy” as the blogger recommended when it isn’t possible to know what might provoke a sexual response in some other person. Of course, I don’t believe modesty requires us to mindread, so this is my response: I argue strongly against a definition of modesty that requires trying to anticipate... Read more