Idaho Lawmaker: Stay-At-Home Order ‘No Different Than Nazi Germany’

Idaho Lawmaker: Stay-At-Home Order ‘No Different Than Nazi Germany’ April 19, 2020

Deplorable: Comparing nonessential workers to Holocaust victims, GOP Rep. Heather Scott claims Idaho’s stay-at-home order is “no different than Nazi Germany.”

The Spokesman-Review reports:

Idaho state Rep. Heather Scott has suggested workers deemed “nonessential” during the COVID-19 pandemic are being treated like Jews during the Holocaust.

Scott, a Republican whose district includes Bonner County, compared Gov. Brad Little’s shutdown orders to Nazi Germany during an hourlong Zoom interview with Jess Fields, a Houston-based podcast host, that was posted online Thursday. She referred to the governor as “Little Hitler” and questioned his authority to decide who can and can’t continue working during the pandemic.

KXLY reports:

A North Idaho representative recently compared the temporary shutdown of nonessential businesses to Jewish people in the Holocaust who were sent to concentration camps.

District 1 Republican Representative Heather Scott made the comments in at least two recorded interviews this month with hosts of podcasts and other shows posted to YouTube.

Complaining about Idaho Republican Governor Brad Little’s stay-at-home order, an order no different than orders delivered by a majority of state governors, Rep. Scott declared:

When you have government telling you that your business is essential or nonessential, and another one – you know, yours is nonessential and someone else’s is essential, we have a problem there. I mean, that’s no different than Nazi Germany, where you had government telling people, ‘You are an essential worker or a nonessential worker,’ and the nonessential workers got put on a train.

Scott’s remarks are deplorable, ignorant, and profoundly disturbed. 

Commenting on Scott’s controversial remarks, Brenda Hammond, president of the Bonner County Human Rights Task Force, said

It makes my heart heavy to hear a comment from an elected official that shows such deep disregard and lack of respect for what the Jewish people experienced during the time of the Holocaust. It also shows an extreme ignorance of history.

Her words will be especially hard for members of our community whose own relatives were put on those trains. Not to mention the few Holocaust survivors we are still privileged to have living among us.

Writing for The Spokesman-Review, Chad Sokol reports on Scott’s nefarious past: 

Scott is no stranger to controversy. During a 2015 campaign rally, she posed with a Confederate flag. In 2017, she defended white nationalism on her Facebook page. Later that year, in an open legislative session, she accused another female lawmaker of offering sexual favors to gain a seat on a House committee. And she recently sponsored a bill to remove some requirements to report domestic and child abuse.

Bottom line: Comparing nonessential workers to Holocaust victims, GOP Rep. Heather Scott claims Idaho’s stay-at-home order is “no different than Nazi Germany.”

Idaho Lawmaker: Stay-At-Home Order ‘No Different Than Nazi Germany’ (Image via Screen Grab)
Idaho Lawmaker: Stay-At-Home Order ‘No Different Than Nazi Germany’ (Image via Screen Grab)

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!