Blogging about Jesus Mythicism: The story so far

Blogging about Jesus Mythicism: The story so far May 23, 2011

Regular readers of Exploring Our Matrix know that one of the topics I have been blogging about for some time is mythicism – the viewpoint that Jesus is more likely to be a purely fictional figure invented more-or-less from scratch based on earlier mythical figures and texts, than to be a historical figure around whom myths and legends subsequently developed. It is not a viewpoint that historians and scholars find persuasive, and since the agreement of experts often fails to mitigate the spread of ill-founded ideas on the internet, I’ve devoted a fair amount of time to explaining why almost no one who knows anything about how historical scholarship works, or takes the time to be well informed about ancient Judaism and/or the New Testament, finds the claims of mythicists to represent scholarship of any sort, much less persuasive scholarship.

On this blog in its old location, I recently posted a round-up of my earlier blogging on this subject, which I thought it would be useful to link to. I had also begun blogging through Earl Doherty’s tome, Jesus: Neither God Nor Man – The Case for a Mythical Jesus, and so I likewise thought that a round-up of links to my previous blog posts about that book should be posted here before proceeding further.

Beginning Blogging Earl Doherty’s Book, Jesus: Neither God Nor Man

The Introduction to Earl Doherty’s Book Jesus: Neither God Nor Man

Chapter 1

Chapter 2


If Your Claims Are Unpersuasive, Is It My Fault?

Chapter 3

Chapter 4

Chapter 5

Dealing Appropriately with Pseudoscholarship

Overview of Part 1

Very shortly I will pick up where I left off. with part two.

"No. My critique has nothing to do with a 'no true Scotsman' fallacy. My 'critique' ..."

The Aims and Ending of Luke-Acts
"Most of Mark 13, at least up to v 32, is referring to the time ..."

The Aims and Ending of Luke-Acts
"In your post above you were making an argument against the 'early' dating of Acts ..."

The Aims and Ending of Luke-Acts
"You said "But he needs to be later than “many” of them". And you appear ..."

The Aims and Ending of Luke-Acts

Browse Our Archives