Special Offers

Buddhist Catholic Contemplative Evangelical General Christian Hindu Jewish Latter-day Saint Muslim New Visions Progressive Christian

Wonka vs. Mythicists (plus the Historical Jesus, Unicorns and Atlantis)

Last updated on: March 22, 2012 at 11:32 pm by James F. McGrath

Joel Watts – sorry, Willy Wonka – makes an apt comparison on Joel’s blog:

Joel also links to my response to Carrier, and emphasizes in the process that, while matters such as whether Jesus was the Messiah are questions that depend on faith, the question of whether there was an ancient human being around whom the movement later known as Christianity formed is not a matter of faith, but of historical evidence and deduction.

Mike Bird quotes Chris Keith in relation to the historical Jesus, unicorns, and Atlantis. It sounds like it should help the mythicists, but in fact it illustrates just how far behind the times mythicists are with respect to the discussion of history, memory, and scholarly methodologies.

Chuck Grantham pointed out that Bart Ehrman’s book, Did Jesus Exist?: The Historical Argument for Jesus of Nazareth, is available for Kindle.

The blog Irreducible Complexity expresses well what mythicists would need in order to be taken seriously – someone who does what plenty of mainstream scholars have done, namely challenge the consensus from the inside offering persuasive scholarly arguments. While Mark Goodacre has not persuaded everyone to abandon the Q hypothesis, he is a respected member of the academy because his work is serious and scholarly, even if not found decisive by many of his peers. Challenges to scholarly consensus are constant in the academy. The problem with mythicism is not that the academy doesn’t allow challenges on this point. The problem is that mythicists are not pursuing scholarly careers, scholarly publication of their arguments, or anything that does more than try to don a thin veneer of the appearance of scholarship while lacking the substance. If mythicists want to be taken seriously, they need to get over their persecution complex and actually do scholarship.

Responding to Richard Carrier's Response to Bart Ehrman

March 23, 2012 Have You Had This Debate?

Browse Our Archives

TAKE THE

Religious Wisdom Quiz

Who saw a vision of a valley of dry bones?

Select your answer to see how you score.

Related posts from Religion Prof: The Blog of James F. McGrath

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian

view all Progressive Christian blogs