The Ossuary Formerly Known as the “Jonah Ossuary”

The Ossuary Formerly Known as the “Jonah Ossuary” April 12, 2012

A movement is afoot to ditch the term “Jonah ossuary” which reflects an interpretation that most do not find plausible, and substitute another nickname, such as the “amphora ossuary” or, if that isn’t catchy enough, the “handled fish ossuary.”

In The Bible and Interpretation James Tabor recounts James Charlesworth’s claim to have found the name of Jonah embedded in the inscription. The Globe and Mail features the news.

Steve Caruso gives the suggestion a failing grade, in a blog post that includes this image:

And Bob Cargill suggests that if one is willing to try to turn all lines and scratches into letters, then one can find other names besides Jonah on the ossuary:

Mark Goodacre lists the top ten problems with the claims being made about the ossuary and the inscription on it. James Tabor responded. The Duke Chronicle has an interview with Mark Goodacre and Eric Meyers about the subject.

Eerdmans announced that they will be publishing a volume on the Talpiot controversies.

Antonio Lombatti, John ByronKen Schenck, Jim West (several times), Jim Davila, Joel WattsSharon Hill, and others have also commented on this topic (or shared images on Pinterest). And if you haven’t seen it yet, last but not least, here is a second video that Bob Cargill shared yesterday:

UPDATE: Here is a link to the CNN video of Bob Cargill being interviewed. Mark Goodacre shows how the alleged stick-man has kept changing.


"So great to hear you get the point of what Paul is saying."

Mythicism and the Early Christian Band
"In Galatians 1:12, Paul says that he was not taught his gospel, and he says ..."

Mythicism and the Early Christian Band
"He says they added nothing to his gospel message. Where exactly does he say he ..."

Mythicism and the Early Christian Band
"I am amused you put evangelical christianity in parenthesis. It is possible the sexism resides ..."

Is (Evangelical) Christianity Irredeemably Patriarchal?

Browse Our Archives

error: Content is protected !!