A Nativity Minus the Migrants and Middle-Easterners

A Nativity Minus the Migrants and Middle-Easterners December 14, 2016

Migrant-Free Nativity
The title that the above was given when I first encountered it was “A nativity scene without Jews, Arabs, Africans or refugees.” The question of where the magi came from is left out – Persia (modern day Iran), perhaps, which may or may not be considered the Middle East, depending on where one chooses to draw one’s arbitrary lines. Of course, the Magi shouldn’t be at the manger (which shouldn’t be in a stable, but that’s a different issue, on which see Stephen Carlson’s article, Ian Paul’s blog post, and of course Kenneth Bailey’s famous work on the topic). But the star overhead hints that they ought to have been present. The shepherds would have been poor and Jewish. Joseph and Mary were Jewish migrants, who according to Matthew’s story, would also become refugees. And Mary was an unwed mother.

Depending on how one wants to frame it, one can highlight that the nativity above is free of Iranians, refugees, poor people, foreigners, Middle Eastern people, (im)migrants, pagans, and unwed mothers.

What seems clear, however one frames it, is that people who hate those who are different from themselves will largely end up with the same nativity scene – one devoid of people.

"When the show first came on I thought there may be a joke in there ..."

Emergency Clerical Hologram
"“Would a holographic chaplain be better than nothing when no human clergy are available?”Best idea ..."

Emergency Clerical Hologram
"Clearly you aren't familiar with John Muir. In a sense in Avatar the main character ..."

Emergency Clerical Hologram

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • winmeer

    Christianity came from the Middle East-Jesus, Mary, Joseph, the 3 kings came from the East, the apostles, the first Christians. Europeans seem to like the ideas except the Jews whom they persecuted.

  • Andrew James Blair

    Europeans may like the idea but it is losing ground in America and Australia, and I think the Nativity pictured above is a Sermon that needs Preaching. There are still those in this world who do not believe Jesus was Jewish.