Index: The Argument from Silence

Index: The Argument from Silence July 7, 2012

The purpose this post is to provide an index for all of my Secular Outpost articles regarding the argument from silence.

Part 1: The Bayesian Interpretation: the logical form of an explanatory argument from silence

Part 2: Peter Kirby’s First Argument from Silence Against the Empty Tomb“: a formal analysis and critique of Kirby’s argument based upon the (alleged) silence of early Christian sources (other than the canonical gospels) regarding the empty tomb
“Part 3: Peter Kirby’s Second Argument from Silence Against the Empty Tomb”:  a formal analysis and critique of Kirby’s argument based upon the absence of evidence that Christians venerated Jesus’ burial place
Part 4: Absence of Denials of Jesus’ Historicity as Evidence for Jesus’ Historicity“: formal statement and defense of an argument for the historicity of Jesus based upon the absence of evidence that anyone in the first two centuries, including opponents of Christianity, denied historicity.
“Part 5: W.L. Craig on Absence Competing Burial Traditions as Evidence for the pre-Markan Burial Tradition”:  a formal analysis and critique of William Lane Craig’s argument from silence for the pre-Markan burial tradition
“Part 6: Uta Ranke-Heinemann on Paul’s Silence about the Empty Tomb”: a formal analysis and critique of Uta Ranke-Heinemann’s argument that Paul’s silence about the empty tomb proves there was no empty tomb.
“Part 7: Victor Stenger on the Absence of Scientific Evidence for God”: a critique of Victor Stenger’s appeal to the Lack of Evidence Argument (LEA) for atheism.
Part 8: The Missing Links Argument against Biological Evolution“: a critique of the popular anti-evolution argument based on missing transitional fossils
Part 9: Mormonism’s Missing Golden Plates“: an argument against Mormonism based upon the missing “Golden Plates”

Related Resources“: contains a bibliography of academic resources and links to select blog posts about arguments from silence

"Good point, I never thought of the relationship between these arguments that way before. But ..."

When Are Appeals to Human Ignorance ..."
"Still bogged down with "real" work. I should finally have time tomorrow (3/22) to post ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?
"Ron,Perhaps I should have said that "infinitesimal" probability does not mean impossibility. Infinitesimal probability is ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?
"I agree; to say that God does not conform to logic does give him a ..."

The Possible Worlds Argument

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment