Ain’t No Flies on Elvis

Ain’t No Flies on Elvis April 13, 2017

Elvis Presley was born on January 8th in 1935.  If he was alive today, he would be 82 years old.  Elvis died on August 16th in 1977, but many have claimed to have seen Elvis alive since that time.  Such sightings are still being reported:

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/578658/elvis-presley-birthday-not-dead-died-alive

http://www.express.co.uk/news/weird/683314/ELVIS-NOT-DEAD-Graceland-groundsman-filmed-THIS-MONTH-is-King-aged-81

And there is even an Elvis Sighting Society, where people share and discuss such events:

http://elvissightingsociety.org/

But what if someone could actually PROVE that Elvis was alive today?  If this could be proven, would it be reasonable to conclude that Elvis had risen from the dead?

Before it would be reasonable to conclude that Elvis had risen from the dead, it would first need to be proven that Elvis really did die on August 16th in 1977.  The fact, if it were to become a fact, that Elvis is now alive, would be very powerful evidence that Elvis did NOT die back in 1977.  Perhaps his death was faked.  Perhaps the autopsy was faked.  Perhaps Elvis did experience clinical death for an hour or so, but was resuscitated by natural means or causes.  If Elvis was proven to be alive today, that would also be powerful evidence that rumors of his death in 1977 were greatly exaggerated.

The same logic applies to Jesus.  If someone someday somehow, per impossible, ever manages to prove that Jesus was alive and walking around on the first Easter Sunday, then this would also provide very powerful evidence against the claim that Jesus had died on the cross on Good Friday.  So, if someone someday somehow, per impossible, ever manages to prove that Jesus was alive and walking around on the first Easter Sunday, that person will have provided us skeptics with a very powerful argument AGAINST the resurrection of Jesus, because they will have provided us with very powerful evidence that Jesus did NOT die on the cross on Good Friday.

William Lane Craig fails to understand this simple bit of logic, and as a result he makes no serious effort to provide proof that Jesus did in fact die on the cross on Good Friday.  Thus, the case for the resurrection of Jesus made by Craig is a complete failure.  Craig (mistakenly) believes that he has proven that Jesus was alive and walking around on the first Easter Sunday, but he fails to realize that if his case really did prove this to be a FACT, that his case would also provide a very powerful reason to reject the claim that Jesus rose from the dead, because this fact would cast serious doubt on the claim that Jesus died on the cross.

"Interesting connection there with language. That makes more sense, thanks, though still has issues."

Some Reflections on Epistemology
"Phil Tanny - It has been two days now. Are you planning to respond?"

Some Reflections on Epistemology
"However, if it appears that all you can muster after posting many comments and replies ..."

Some Reflections on Epistemology
"Not interested until someone demonstrates that the rules of human reason are binding on everything ..."

Some Reflections on Epistemology

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment