Matthew Flannagan and Jason Thibodeau Discuss the Euthyphro Dilemma

Matthew Flannagan and Jason Thibodeau Discuss the Euthyphro Dilemma September 24, 2018

On Saturday (9/22) I was privileged to join Matthew Flannagan for a dialogue about the Euthyphro dilemma. Cameron Bertuzzi of Capturing Christianity hosted the dialogue and livestreamed it from the Capturing Christianity YouTube channel. I did my best to explain why I think that there are some compelling Euthyphro-inspired objections to divine command theory, and Matthew offered powerful and thoughtful responses to these objections. In my humble opinion the conversation was thorough, thoughtful, and friendly. It is one of the most rewarding conversations I have had about the Euthyphro problem.

Many of the regular readers out The Secular Outpost will know that Matthew is an expert in the field of theistic ethics (you can watch one of his lectures about divine command theory and the Euthyphro problem here.)  He is the co-author, with Paul Copan, of Did God Really Command Genocide? He and I have had some exchanges about Euthyphro and divine command theory here at the Secular Outpost and also at his blog (see, e.g., here and here). I have always had a great deal of respect for the intellectual rigor he brings to any discussion. I learned a great deal from Matthew during this conversation (as well as in our previous exchanges) and I want to thank him for sharing his considerable knowledge and intellectual talents.

I also want to thank Cameron for hosting this discussion and for the work he does at Capturing Christianity, which brings together theists and non-thesists in friendly dialogue. He regularly hosts very good conversations about topics in the philosophy of religion, apologetics, and counter-apologetics.

You can watch the entire discussion below.


"C.H. Dodd was a long time ago his view is really antiquated.Gospel is not an ..."

Hinman’s Defense of his Sad Little ..."
"I would like to discuss that. I suggest you come to the cadre blog. I ..."

Hinman’s Defense of his Sad Little ..."
"When you have peeled all the layers of an onion only a fool would assert ..."

Hinman’s Defense of his Sad Little ..."
"Brad says: "all concluded that “the Fourth Gospel is historically reliable.” after they had engaged ..."

Hinman’s Defense of his Sad Little ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment