Links: Two Metaethical Arguments for Atheism from John J Park

Links: Two Metaethical Arguments for Atheism from John J Park January 4, 2019

Park, John. “The Moral Epistemological Argument for Atheism.” European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 7, no. 1 (n.d.): 121. doi:10.24204/EJPR.V7I1.133.

Abstract: Numerous supposed immoral mandates and commands by God found in religious texts are introduced and discussed. Such passages are used to construct a logical contradiction contention that is called the moral epistemological argument. It is shown how there is a contradiction in that God is omnibenevolent, God can instruct human beings, and God at times provideus with unethical orders and laws. Given the existence of the contradiction, it is argued that an omnibenevolent God does not exist. Finally, this contention is defended from several objections.

Park, John Jung. “The Problem of Error: The Moral Psychology Argument for Atheism.” Erkenntnis, n.d. doi:10.1007/S10670-017-9900-8.

Abstract: The problem of error is an old argument for atheism that can be found in Medieval and Early Modern Philosophy. Although it is not widely discussed in the contemporary literature in the Philosophy of Religion, I resurrect it and give it a modern spin. By relying on empirical studies in moral psychology that demonstrate that moral judgments from human beings are generally susceptible to certain psychological biases, such as framing and order effects, I claim that if God is responsible for making human beings such that we have these biases, this means that God is not a perfect being. The findings in empirical moral psychology create a problem for the existence of God, traditionally conceived.

"The above thoughts are what makes it seem so strange to me for Aquinas to ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?
"Humans are necessary by hypothetical necessity, as instruments by which cats are enabled fully to ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?
"The central conundrum that powers the FTA is the ridiculously tight range of physical parameters ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?
"My thought is the same, along with stars. They might really be why the universe ..."

Do We Need a Finely-Tuned God?

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment