Hosea was disqualified because he could basically fit every song. Yes, this turns Jay-Z into Gomer.
Pray You Catch Me–Eli
Hold Up–Samuel
Don’t Hurt Yourself–Elijah, feat. Jack White as Elisha
Sorry–Jeremiah
6 Inch–Isaiah (part 1)
Daddy Lessons–Nathan, the story-time prophet.
Love Drought–Isaiah (part 2)
Sandcastles–Isaiah (part 3)
Forward–Ezra
Freedom–Moses, duh.
All Night–That was also Moses.
Formation–I don’t know…Amos?