Should Alan Turing Be “Pardoned”?

Should Alan Turing Be “Pardoned”? December 23, 2013

Today Alan Turing, computer science pioneer, inventor of the “Turing Test”, and Second World War Hero, was pardoned by the British crown. The pardon repeals his conviction for “gross indecency” – he admitted to having a homosexual relationship after his house was burgled by an acquaintance of his lover, and was promptly prosecuted and plied with hormone treatment which made him impotent. He lost his security clearance and could no longer advise the government on cryptography and, two years later, he died in what an inquest determined to be suicide.

Of the pardon The Independent writes:

nearly 60 years after his suicide from cyanide poisoning at the age of 41, Alan Turing has been officially pardoned  by the Queen under the little-known Royal Prerogative of Mercy.

The pardon comes after a change of heart by ministers who had previously insisted that Turing was properly convicted of what at the time was a criminal offence.

I support wholeheartedly the efforts to rehabilitate the good name of Turing, who was a genius and a national hero. I support the campaign for the pardon and the urge behind it: it is rooted in a genuine desire to vindicate a great figure in the history of science who was the victim of prejudice. The fact this pardon was awarded demonstrates the great social progress which has been made in only a few decades – progress which is to be welcomed.

Yet the nature of the pardon makes me wary: we should not forget that the party who committed the true crime in this instance was the British government, for prosecuting and chemically castrating a man for an “offense” which was an offense against no one. That this “pardon” was enacted through the Royal Prerogative of Mercy strikes me wrong, as if clemency is being provided someone who has indeed done something wrong. Mercy is offered to the guilty, after all, not the innocent.

In this instance the party who should sue for mercy is the crown itself, for legitimating a wicked conviction. Whether we grant a pardon is up to us.

"Ten years since dad died, while I held him, five since mum. Not a day ..."

Life Without Dad
"People who think that chopping the ends of male babies dicks off is a path ..."

Former Chief Rabbi of Great Britain ..."
"Mike Brown wasn't murdered, not sure how you missed that minor detail."

Closing the Doors of the Temple
"Thus we conclude with that classic chestnut that characterizes all dispassionate rational discourse: angrily storming ..."

Skepticism and Social Justice

Browse Our Archives