Is a fascist Christian theocracy REALLY the stuff of paranoia?

Is a fascist Christian theocracy REALLY the stuff of paranoia? June 23, 2017

When Hulu launched its highly-acclaimed dramatisation of Margaret Atwood’s 1985 novel The Handmaid’s Tale earlier this year, Barbara Kay, writing for The National Post, had this to say:

Atwood chose evangelical Christians as her villains, because their family structures are patriarchal. But patriarchy doesn’t necessarily imply misogyny. In fact, I found Atwood’s demonizing scenario rather hilarious. Pious Christians are the last people on earth to dream up a system in which the state has control over everyone’s sexual and reproductive lives

My jaw dropped, not the least because, as chief court reporter for The Star in Johannesburg in the early 1970s, I covered numerous trials of people who had the misfortune to fall foul of the Immorality Act, devised by the Christian apartheid regime and gleefully supported by the Much Deformed Church Dutch Reformed Church to prevent “miscegenation” – sex across what was termed the “colour bar”.
The most infamous of these was the Excelsior trial of five prominent white Afrikaners and 14 black women. (Originally seven whites were arrested. Charges against one was dropped and another – a local councillor-cum-village-butcher – committed suicide.) A third, if I recall correctly, tried to blow his brains out, but succeeded only in blinding himself in one eye.

At the start of the trial I was in this dusty little Orange Free State dorp (population 700) – together with a posse of reporters from around the world – when, to the everyone’s amazement, charges against all the defendants were dropped.
Excelsior possessed just one public telephone booth – and there was a stampede by hacks to get it when the trial was abandoned. Being a fit 24-year-old at the time – and probably the youngest (and most sober) in the pack – I got to it first and breathlessly dictated a report which earned me the front page lead in The Star that day – and the biggest byline of my career.
This from Wikipedia:

The Immorality Act was the title of two acts of the Parliament of South Africa which prohibited, amongst other things, sexual relations between white people and people of other races. The first Immorality Act, of 1927, prohibited sex between whites and blacks, until amended in 1950 to prohibit sex between whites and all non-whites. The second Immorality Act, of 1957, continued this prohibition and also dealt with many other sex offences. The ban on interracial sex was lifted in 1985, but certain sections of the 1957 act dealing with prostitution remain in force as the “Sexual Offences Act, 1957”.

One could be jailed for up to seven years for inter-racial sex acts.

Pious Christians are the last people on earth to dream up a system in which the state has control over everyone’s sexual and reproductive lives

Yeah, right!
Inevitably, one of the first to fall foul of the Act was a Dutch Reformed Church cleric.

At Barkly East in the Cape, the dominee was caught in the act in his garage built by his parishioners next to his house.
Although he was given only a suspended sentence, his irate parishioners bulldozed the offending garage to the ground.
Over the next few decades, thousands of people were charged under the Act, after being caught by police who seemed to spend inordinate parts of their working day hiding in trees with binoculars trained on bedroom windows of suspects, and testing sheets for evidence that two people were sharing a bed.

This prompted a University of Natal staff member to pen a humorous poem about the wayward priest.
Meanwhile, the Excelsior affair inspired Zakes Mda to write a novel called The Madonna of Excelsior (2002).

Back to The Handmaid’s Tale

I have not seen any of the episodes of the Hulu series, which are currently available in the UK via Channel 4, but last night I began re-watching my copy of the 1990 movie written by acclaimed British playwright Harold Pinter.

It features, among others, Robert Duvall, above, who plays “The Commander” – a state-approved rapist with a bloody great Bible – and Faye Dunaway. The film, with its absence of black actors, remains true to Attwood’s portrayal of the Republic of Gilead as being a white Christian supremacist state, but the new series, as the header picture shows, does feature actors of colour.
The Christian site Movieguide uses one word to describe Volker Schlondorff’s film in the lead-in to its review: “Abhorrent”.
Then it unleashes a tirade:

ANTI-CHRISTIAN BIGOTRY; Profanity and obscenity; adultery, lesbianism and female nudity; violence; and, blasphemous distortions of Scripture.

The reviewer then veers completely off the subject to make this astonishing claim:

The proliferation of Christianity has always brought greater literacy to a culture, while humanism has decreased literacy.

This is a flat-out lie. Recent research has shown that the most literate countries in the world also happen to be the most godless.
Finland ranks as the most literate nation in the world.

Nearly one out of every five people in Finland is not a member of a religious organisation. The number of persons with no religious affiliation has doubled in two decades.

Iceland is the third most literate country. A 2016 poll shows that not a single Icelander aged 25 or under believes that God created the world.
Among other countries with the highest literacy rates are Norway, Denmark, Sweden and the Netherlands – all of which have very low levels of religious beliefs, according to a 2009 Gallup Poll.
Oh,  and the least religious countries are also the happiest.
Movieguide’s mendacity doesn’t stop there:

True Christianity has been known throughout history for its care and compassion for all races and religions, while socialism produced the holocaust in Germany and the Gulag and purges in the Soviet Union.
Christianity values individuality because God created and loves each individual, while humanism has always sought conformity. Christianity has always stressed stewardship over all creation, while humanism has spawned genetic engineering, death camps and the murder of innocents.

I actually love Movieguide. I’ve lost track of the number of truly brilliant movies I have seen after reading reviews on the site. If Movieguide says “abhorrent” you can be assured that it’s well worth watching. One that immediately springs to mind is Captain Fantastic, described by the site as:

Very strong humanist, Anti-American, anti-capitalist, socialist worldview with very strong attacks (including at least one foul-mouthed attack) on ‘organized religion’ and belief in God and one on Christians making them out to be the worst of the worst.

It’s nothing short of … fantastic.

"The only "age-inappropriate indoctrination of children" is the indoctrination of religion by using lies to ..."

Prejudice, not pride: London school targeted ..."
"https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c..."

Prejudice, not pride: London school targeted ..."
"There;s nothing controversial about being kind and showing tolerance.Unless you're an asshole."

Prejudice, not pride: London school targeted ..."
"CoastalMaineBird"wounded in the stones" that has got to be painful!"

Paranoid Scottish Catholics fear their faith ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • John the Drunkard

    African-Americans seem to be among the most priest-ridden people in the developed world. The religion imposed upon them by their erstwhile owners is still crushing them a century and a half later.
    So, the ‘integration’ of Gilead is not that much of a distortion of Atwood’s message.

  • L.Long

    ” Pious Christians are the last people on earth to dream up a system in which the state has control over everyone’s sexual and reproductive lives … ” LOLFDF…She is a dimwitted idiot to say such a really stoopid thing!!

  • Gui

    Regarding the genetic engineering: doesn’t eugeny and ethnocentrism were largely accepted during a long time in so called christian countries like the USA?

  • It’s true: Christianity could some day become what Islam is now.

  • barriejohn

    This morning’s news: Andrea Leadweight (Leader of the House of Commons) says that the media need to be “more patriotic” when reporting Brexit negotiations etc!*
    (* On the BBC, of course, which is notoriously Left/Right Wing, depending upon your particular point of view, and can be implicitly threatened with the withdrawal of funding.)

  • barriejohn

    Re the nefarious activities of Movieguide, this story is, to use a much-overworked internet term, hilarious:

  • Stuart

    “Atwood chose evangelical Christians as her villains”. In the book, I’m fairly sure that they were muslims that had gained power?

  • 1859

    @ John the Drunk:
    The same is true of most of the colonised parts of Africa, The Philippines, The Pacific Islands, New Zealand, the whole of South and Central America – the indigenous peoples are the most fervent followers of their conqueror’s religion. It might have originally been some sublimated act of survival – believe in what the white men say about their god, supplicate yourself completely to their deity and the white men won’t kill you. Who knows? But it is very sad to see so many good people around the world swallowed up in another culture’s religious fantasies.

  • Paul

    I spoke to a white Saffer the other day who was a deeply religious christian – big white rugby loving saffer who now doesn’t drink! Oh ok.
    I told him I had been to SA a few times pre and post apartheid and commented and asked him about the apartheid regime being a white deeply Christian regime. He denied this.

  • tonye

    If you get a moment please read Movieguide’s review of the movie Creation.
    I remember a fairly gentle movie but the review they give is almost rabid.

  • barriejohn

    @tonye: I thought that Barry had mentioned that, but I can only find an article about the film itself, and that goes back a few years now! This is what you meant, though:
    “Well Made Propaganda, But a Lie Nonetheless”

  • remigius
  • tonye

    @barriejohn, remigius,

  • barriejohn

    I did find it, but I obviously missed the reference to Movieguide!

  • John

    I lived and worked in apartheid South Africa as a professional musician during the early/mid 1970s.
    One contract our band had took us to Bloemfontein, the capital of the Orange Free State.
    I heard about the miscegenation case mentioned in the above article and I was also told that after some leading Afrikaners committed suicide, the Nationalist Minister of Justice had ordered that only he could take the decision to prosecute any future persons involved.
    Thereafter, there were no further prosecutions.
    Effectively, miscegenation became legalised.
    The law stayed on the statute book but was unenforced.
    Now apartheid Israel is going in the opposite direction.

  • norman ravitch

    Christianity was the earliest form of Fascism. It was also the earliest form of mental illness.