Op-ed: Vatican abuse summit was an exercise in arse-covering

Op-ed: Vatican abuse summit was an exercise in arse-covering February 26, 2019
Images via YouTube

BARRY Duke has pointed out the cowardice and uselessness of the Vatican’s latest bafflegab on priestly child rape, but it’s a subject that frankly requires a lot of hostile commentary, and I want to dig into the theology of it all.

The Holy See Press Office (yes really, that’s what it calls itself) has kindly provided us with a translation of Frank’s summing up – or as the press office described it, “his concluding address to the presidents of the Episcopal Conferences of the Catholic Church, the heads of the Oriental Catholic Churches, to the representatives of the Union of Superiors General, and the members of the Roman Curia and of the Council of Cardinals who participated in the meeting on ‘The Protection of Minors in the Church’, which took place in the Vatican from 21 to 24 February 2019.”

They don’t call him Frank though.

It all sounds so official and important, doesn’t it. It sounds legitimate. It’s meant to. Humans are so easily fooled and manipulated by that kind of thing – by the parade of titles and offices, the Roman Curias and Councils of Cardinals; we’re nudged into thinking it has some kind of genuine claim to our attention even if we’re not Catholics, even if we are skeptical or furious about the whole fraudulent thing.

Image via YouTube

So now that we’re properly cowed and humbled by the Procession of Ecclesiastical Nomenclature, let’s look at how Frank presents this worrying puzzle of how Mister God let all this rape of children by priests go on for decades and, it seems safe to assume, centuries.

Dear Brothers and Sisters,

As I thank the Lord who has accompanied us during these days, I would like to thank all of you for the ecclesial spirit and concrete commitment that you have so generously demonstrated.

Problem. We have a problem already. It’s sweet that the Lord accompanied them during those days, but where was the Lord the rest of the time? Where was the Lord during all those rapes of children? If the Lord accompanies them now as they try to deal with the fact that they can’t hide the rapes any longer, why didn’t the Lord accompany them as they pulled down the children’s pants?

Why didn’t the Lord whisper in their ears, or stir their consciences to do the whispering, that it’s not right for grown men in positions that children have been taught to see as next to that very Lord to rape those same children? Why accompany them now, when it’s too late for all those generations of children, and not then, when the priests were busily ruining their lives?

Now, I can take a wild guess without reading ahead that it will be the usual tortured reasoning about free will and finding our own consciences and yadda yadda, but that is just arse-covering and nothing else. The church has been dragged kicking and screaming into admitting, as slowly as it possibly can and with as much excuse-making as it possibly can, that it has done nothing while thousands of children have been sexually assaulted by Mister God’s representatives on earth.

It’s way past the point where they get to claim this was all a moral lesson taught by Mister God. If the Lord accompanied them during the meeting then the Lord accompanied the priests as they raped the children, so the Lord has some explaining to do.

In other words, that’s the problem they have throughout, and it’s one they can’t solve. They should have known better, and knowing better should have made them not do it, but they didn’t and it didn’t, and that means their precious church is not some magic pipeline to the source of all Goodness. That means their precious church is just another gang of self-interested men doing what they can get away with.

Back to Frank’s bum-covering:

Our work has made us realize once again that the gravity of the scourge of the sexual abuse of minors is, and historically has been, a widespread phenomenon in all cultures and societies. Only in relatively recent times has it become the subject of systematic research, thanks to changes in public opinion regarding a problem that was previously considered taboo; everyone knew of its presence yet no one spoke of it.

Boom, there it is, the moral relativism ploy – the one ploy an absolutist god-fanatic cannot use. Oh but public opinion has changed, murmurs Frank, hoping no one will notice that the church is supposed to be eternal and 100% morally correct. If public opinion has changed, Frank, what does that tell you about your god?

Doesn’t it tell you that your god either changes its moral views along with the rest of us, or that it just plain doesn’t care about human suffering and thus is no friend of ours? Why is the church’s behavior changing in response to public pressure now that public opinion has changed, when the church is supposed to speak for Mister God and thus have perfect, flawless, eternal, absolute morality forever and ever amen?

Frank’s next move is to go on and on and on about all the child abuse there is that’s not committed by priests. Ah that’s attractive, it’s just as attractive as hulking Billy on the playground who gets told not to hit other children and whines that Bobby hit a child last week. Billy on the playground, however, is not Frank at the Vatican, and Frank is. Frank and his institution make vast claims to moral righteousness and to the right to make rules that are binding on all of us, including non-Catholics.

Frank and his subordinates have no qualms about forcibly preventing women from obtaining abortions, whether they are Catholic or Baptist or atheist. Frank and his church take democratic governments to court to force them to keep women from getting contraception. They have enough moral conceit and confidence to do all that and much more, yet they’re such moral voids that they whine “Everyone else does it!” when they can no longer conceal their history of raping children behind the altar. It’s brazen and disgusting and contemptible.

Enough already.

""About bloody time god made an appearance." I love it!"

Notre Dame blaze: right-wing loons are ..."
"Where were "the shots of the crowds gathered outside as the fire blazed, singing hymns ..."

BBC excoriated by ex-staffer for being ..."
"It's a tourist trap, owned by the French state. Stop whining, bitch."

BBC excoriated by ex-staffer for being ..."
"Thanks for the offer, but I only needed enough pieces for a deck, not a ..."

BBC excoriated by ex-staffer for being ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Tawreos

    This was always going to be one big PR circle jerk for them. They waited so long to have it to see if any of the excuses they had previously offered took hold and one did. Many people blame the homosexuals in the church for the rapes and that relieves the “good” priests from any blame. All they did was talk a bit and promise to do some things and tomorrow a kid will get raped and next week a the rapist will show up in a new diocese and the catholics in the pews will point to this and say it proves that the church has changed.

    The whole organization needs to be brought down and damned soon.

  • John Pieret

    If the Lord accompanied them during the meeting then the Lord accompanied the priests as they raped the children, so the Lord has some explaining to do.

    Snap!

  • CoastalMaineBird

    Yeah, no surprise. We knew that when the Vatican itself put the kibosh on the U.S. version of the “summit” last fall. The PR department stepped in and said “we got this”.

  • Robert McLean

    Silly Frank’s further buggered the lingering reputation of his outrageously crook cabal of criminal clerics. If their god is an actual thing, it’s a complete failure, in just about everything, mind you, that judgement is based on total inactivity, which strongly suggests perhaps the whole shady show is just that, an outrageous fraud. The perpetrators must hang their silly hatted heads in shame. The whole seedy lot of them. The other versions are hardly any better.

  • Any discussion about George Pell in there? None?

  • Connie Beane

    “…a widespread phenomenon in all cultures and societies….” Translation: We in the Catholic church are no different from anyone else. There’s that old, old excuse of pious frauds everywhere: “Do as we say, not as we do.”