‘Smells and bells’ in a Michigan church results in priest’s removal

‘Smells and bells’ in a Michigan church results in priest’s removal February 10, 2019

LAST December Catholic priest Father Edwin C Dwyer boasted that he was attracting more young people to Our Lady of Peace parish in Bay City by reintroducing traditional Catholic sacramentals such as incense and bells.

Dyer showing off his new frock in a selfie he posted on Facebook

Dyer, 36, said at the time:

Believe it or not, tradition works. So-called ‘old ways’ are quite popular among younger Catholics. Smells, bells, classic hymns, chant, prolonged silence, and, hold on for this one, LATIN are all largely embraced by the younger generations of the Church. Thus, we are going to make Sunday beautiful at Our Lady of Peace.

But then it all went horribly wrong.

Some older members of the congregation – whom one would have thought would welcome a return to “the old ways” with open arms – did just the opposite.

And such was the acrimony that developed that Dwyer has now been removed from his post as chaplain at Saginaw Valley State University by Bishop Walter Hurley, 81, the apostolic administrator of Saginaw – and a man described as “a cretin” and “a predator protector” in a report published last year by Church Militant.

Church Militant quoted investigative reporter Jay McNally, who worked for the Detroit archdiocese in the 1990s, as saying:

If you ever wondered how and why the Catholic Church kept known pedophile priests in action even after victims complained that these priests sodomized them dozens of times annually for years, let me introduce you to Bishop Walter Hurley, one of the most disgusting men I had the misfortune of ever meeting.

After SVSU students protested over their chaplain’s January 31 removal, Hurley announced that Dwyer would be leaving his role as parish administrator, too.

MLive/ YouTube screen grab

In a letter to the congregation of Our Lady of Peace, dated February 1, Bishop Hurley, above, stated that “issues” were dividing the “parish community.”

For some time now I have been aware of a number of issues, particularly with the Liturgy, that have divided the parish community at Our Lady of Peace Parish, Bay City. This is a serious concern in that our worship should draw us together, rather than divide. It is important that we seek ways to unite the parish in our common mission of being evangelizing disciples and grow in our relationship with Christ, each in our own way.

On January 28 and again on January 29 I met with Father Dwyer to discuss divisions within Our Lady of Peace. This meeting was preceded by earlier meetings with our Diocesan staff, including Father Bill Rutkowski, Vicar General and Father Peter Gaspeny, the Regional Vicar.

The bishop said that he then told Dwyer to “step away from the parish for a brief period” and Dwyer “declined” the request.

Reflecting on the mess the diocese now finds itself  in, the bishop said that he had decided to remove the young pastor.

I have withdrawn his present assignment as Parochial Administrator, effective February 8, 2019. The Diocese will have responsibility for his salary, benefits and housing as he awaits a new assignment.

Hurley, according to LifeSiteNews, is now being:

Inundated with correspondence from Catholics incensed at the unjust treatment of a priest guilty of nothing more than wishing to make Sunday worship–and Catholicism–more attractive to young people. Not new to controversy, Hurley has been accused of protecting clerical sexual abusers in the Archdiocese of Detroit before being appointed as Bishop of Grand Rapids.

A request for comment to the Diocese of Saginaw by LifeSiteNews was not returned.

Not altogether surprising, given that his Dyer’s removal was ordered by a bishop who would rather punish a priest for doing his best for his parish than take action against child molesters.

"Wow. That’s pretty bad and very scary."

Former head of a Muslim academy ..."
"Sadly, most (apparently) say that Sharia law and other practices should be imposed world wide.So ..."

Former head of a Muslim academy ..."
"You seem not to understand when to use the Argumentum ad Populum fallacy accusation correctly."

UK body modification trial raises questions ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Jim Jones

    The RCC is a collection of gangs and districts and the bishops are the Mafia bosses.

  • Bubblecar

    Dwyer looks more like an Imam than a priest, right down to the henna-dyed neckbeard, and it does seem to be the case that fundamentalists amongst both Catholics and Protestants are increasingly influenced by radical Islam.

    I’ve no doubt that Bishop Hurley is indeed “disgusting”, but no more disgusting than “Church Militant”, one of the many ultra-fundy Catholic groups whose mission is to drag the Church back to its medieval worst, following the example of Salafism, the Muslim Brotherhood etc.

  • WallofSleep

    Inundated with correspondence from Catholics incensed…”

    No pun intended?

  • Jim Jones

    I wish we could encourage more fighting among these lying idiots.

    “Fight, you bastards. I hate peace”.

  • Jennny

    Old joke: Child went to his first Mass and was asked afterwards what he thought about it. He replied, ‘Well, I was a bit scared when the vicar’s handbag caught fire and he still kept swinging it near me.’

  • CoastalMaineBird

    How sad is it that Incense and Peppermints can attract the young folks to come spend their time ?

  • Daz

    It’s all fun until someone nails a whole bunch of theses to the church door…

  • anxionnat

    Since I was about 3 years old (I’m now 66), I have always vomited when catholic incense got sprayed around the church. At my mom’s funeral in 2009, I spent half of the service outside, throwing up in the bushes. I think it’s likely that every catholic church uses the same recipe as they used in my youth, and that was at least part of my reason for ditching the church.

  • Vanity Unfair

    If you regard a Catholic service as a theatrical performance then surely Latin only adds to the spectacle. Very few people object to La Traviata in Italian, Carmen in French or Lohengrin in German; besides it also has the advantage of not being immediately laughable and if you read the plot of Lohengrin you will know how important that is.

  • Vanity Unfair
  • TheBookOfDavid

    Father Dwyer may have been unfairly removed from his post, but he still owes me a set of drapes.

  • TheBookOfDavid

    Unusual reaction from an institution that prefers to censer dissent.

  • WallofSleep

    I (Holy) See what you did there.

  • WallofSleep

    I have an asthma-like reaction to most incense, as well as most perfumes and hairsprays.

  • anxionnat

    Yes, my youngest brother too. He basically got away with not going to church when he was a kid. Lucky guy.