menu

The Death of Charlie Watts, and Sympathy for the Devil

The Death of Charlie Watts, and Sympathy for the Devil August 31, 2021

I’m not inclined to have morbid thoughts, but I have been wondering for several years which member of the Rolling Stones would be the first to lay down his instrument.

I suspected it would be Keith Richards. He looks a bit rough around the edges. Perhaps Mick Jagger? But at 78, Jagger still prances across the stage with more enthusiasm than many thirty-year-old rockers. What about the Stone’s bassist/guitarist Ronnie Woods, would he be the first to go?

Embed from Getty Images

Incidentally, Woods also happens to be a spectacular artist.

No to all three of the above. Instead, the first member of the Rolling Stones to die was the band’s drummer, Charlie Watts, who passed away last Tuesday on August 24.

The Rolling Stones formed in London back in 1962. In the past 4 decades they’ve put out a whopping 140 studio, live, compilation, and video albums. WOW! They were also just getting ready to go on tour again when they lost Watts. So, whatever success each member of the Stones has reaped, whatever fortunes they’ve amassed, they surely earned it and not necessarily for personal reasons. Rather, it has been their life’s work making millions of people happy through their music, and entertaining people at this level happens to pay quite well.

Sympathy for the devil

One of my favorite songs from the Stones is Sympathy for the Devil released in December 1968. I was six years old at the time, but the tune didn’t drift into my radio waves until I was in high school. I think the reason for this is because this is about this time when my interest in religion and spirituality emerged. Musically speaking, this tune rides on a mesmerizing samba rhythm led by Watts and combined with additional percussive elements. Yet, for anyone who is spiritually inclined the first three verses will lure you in like an enticing temptation.

“Please allow me to introduce myself
I’m a man of wealth and taste
I’ve been around for a long, long years
Stole million man’s soul an faith

And I was ’round when Jesus Christ
Had his moment of doubt and pain
Made damn sure that Pilate
Washed his hands and sealed his fate

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game”

Sex, drugs and rock and roll

Now, a lot of folks don’t like rock and roll music for personal reasons. However, many Christians think rock and roll is downright evil. For these individuals Sympathy for the Devil presents them with a double-edged sword. The song is not only crafted in the devil’s music but it also asks us to empathize with the devil!

But for deeper thinkers the lyrics in this song—particularly the third verse–reveals an insight into one of humanity’s most perplexing conundrums. Which is, the mystery as to why bad things happen in life; or why there is so much pain and suffering in life.

It’s no surprise that Jagger uses biblical imagery and symbolism to get us to ponder this mystery. Jagger is after all, like us, born into a world heavily influenced by biblical mythology. This mythology revolves around the notion that evil is a power that was created by an entity known as Lucifer, and Lucifer, (aka the devil or Satan), uses this evil to reap misery upon humans.

Yet, Jagger goes much deeper than the myth. He admonishes us to think even harder about the role a devil plays in the existence of evil in our world. “But what’s puzzling you . . . “Jaggar taunts, “is the nature of my [the devil’s] game.”

The devil is in the details

The devil, of course, is in the details. Meaning, the Bible offers a lengthy synopsis of the origins and purpose of evil, but anyone who is really investigating the biblical evidence to validate the devil’s relationship with the power of evil will discover just how scanty and contradictory that biblical evidence is.

The gist of what the Bible presents is that Lucifer was a created being who rebelled against God in heaven. Presumably, Lucifer either invented or created evil prior to this rebellion. Lucifer then convinced other angels to rebel as well. This set the stage for a war in heaven between God and Lucifer, thus establishing that two existential powers exist in our universe: the powers of good and evil. After the rebellion, God cast Lucifer to earth where Lucifer was transformed into a snake and permitted to introduce evil to Adam and Eve by way of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. After Adam and Eve ate the fruit from this tree and succumbed to evil, God allowed evil to thrive on earth so future generations could experience this power. This set up a condition in which every person born would experience both good and evil, which is necessary according to biblical tradition to validate that humans were also created with (and offered) the power of choice. This choice also become a test of loyalty. Those who serve God and the power of good will be saved, and those who don’t are followers of Satan and the power of evil.

If you’re a bit “puzzled” by this biblical description, consider yourself a rational person. If this description makes it seem as though life is just a game, then this is precisely the purpose to life that Christianity offers humans. For as far as Christianity and most biblically based religions teach, you were created by God to serve Him and you are destined for eternal hellfire if you don’t.

It’s no surprise that the song “Sympathy for the Devil” uses biblical imagery and symbolism to get us to ponder the mythology of good and evil. / Image by ParallelVision from Pixabay

–“But what’s puzzling you is the nature of this game.”

Volumes have been written to verify or defend these biblical concepts regarding the origins and purpose of evil. I’ve spent years preaching these concepts and denouncing them as both a Christian and a freethinker. So, I’ll not bore you with lengthy arguments here except to end with two of the most important observations any person should consider in trying to validate whether these biblical concepts are true:

  • If God created everything, and there is evil, then God is evil and uses evil to his advantage.

Even if we could prove that an entity such as Lucifer existed, this entity would not have creative powers. Such an individual could only use powers that were already present in the universe it was created into. In which case, any attempt to claim that God represents only the power of good and Lucifer the power of evil is pointless. While some biblical texts might suggest otherwise, Christian tradition fully affirms that God is the creator of evil; that evil is a necessary component of His universe, and that He uses evil to suit his purposes.)

  • If humans are created, then they were merely designed to fulfill a specific function. Thus, you and I are not independent, self-governing individuals, but rather, merely sophisticated robots.

Any God worth His weight in omnipotence could theoretically create and program a humanlike creature to bend the knee and worship Him—providing this God also created these beings with knees to bend and vocal cords to praise Him! In a similar manner, any novice computer programmer can build a computer program along with a voice like Siri’s to tell its creator how wonderful she is every time she boots up her computer. In other words, to be created is a lot like being designed and programmed to function within a specific environment. No God would get any satisfaction out such a contrived form of adoration and praise, which makes it highly unlikely that we were created to fulfill this specific purpose in life.

Grooving like a freethinker

I still enjoy the song Sympathy for the Devil. I like the samba groove it rides on, steered by Watt’s distinctive style. Charlie Watts was one of the most talent drummers of all time, and he will be sorely missed.

Aside from this, the song’s religiously infused lyrics, which once lured me in as kid in my early years of spiritual discovery, no longer holds this freethinker’s attention. The hook the song turns on inviting me to consider Christianity’s teachings regarding the dynamics of good and evil in our world are far too shallow.

I have no sympathy for the devil. I never did even when I believed in one. But I do have a healthy appreciation and desire to better understand the complex relationship between all that is good in this life and all that is bad. To understand this subject more fully one must break with religious tradition altogether and venture into other concepts and ideas. Such as opening the mind to experience and understand different beliefs, ideologies and cultures. Or exploring aspects of modern life such as income inequality or the plight of the poor, needy and voiceless. To this end meditation can help. It’s a powerful tool one can use to begin discarding old, conventional ways of thinking, since it permits the mind to contemplate insights without the pressure to conform to an established methodology of thinking.

About Scott R. Stahlecker
Scott Stahlecker is a former minister and now writes for Thinkadelics about the joys and benefits of living as a freethinker. He is the author of the novel Blind Guides and Picking Wings Off Butterflies. You can read more about the author here.

Browse Our Archives



TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

17 responses to “The Death of Charlie Watts, and Sympathy for the Devil”

  1. They used this song in the tv series Sleepy Hollow.

    The tv series Lucifer goes a little bit into the problem of God creating Lucifer to rebel, then punishing him…for doing what he was created to do. An interesting subplot in the series is that Lucifer never lies, which is congruent with what happens with Eve in the Garden of Eden, when the snake never lies to her. God lies to her and Adam, but Satan never does.

  2. The Lucifer series is based on a comic book series that I never read. The tv series opens with Lucifer in LA, where he’s gone on vacation and stayed for years. He’s the owner of a nightclub named Lux (which is almost Luz, which means “light”) and he grants people favors which then come due whenever he needs anything. He can also compel people to tell him what they really want (their heart’s desire) just by asking them.

    As the series opens, someone Lucifer is fond of is murdered and he crosses paths with the LA police department, where he meets Lt. Chloe Decker (Dancer in the comic books), a strong, smart woman, and falls in love with her.

    The minor arc of the stories is Bad Guy Does Bad Thing police procedural, but the major arc is Lucifer learning who he is and learning to care about the humans around him through his association with Chloe. An unfallen angel tries to bring him back to where he is and various demons try to get him back, as well (apparently Lucifer is good at his job) and throughout most of the run of the show, what God wants is a mystery because he doesn’t make himself known.

    Lucifer doesn’t enjoy being the King of Hell and is only doing the job because God forced him into it. He doesn’t hate people and he never lies to anyone.

    The show plays with family drama writ large and also with the idea that reality is not what it might be taught.

  3. Thanks for the plug on this show. As I was just telling WMDKitty, I’ll have to start watching it myself. One interesting aspect of the show that you mention here is that Lucifer doesn’t want the job God gives him. I’ve never thought of Lucifer in this way, as a real person with interests and desires that differ from how God created him.

  4. One of the running jokes in Lucifer is that it’s LA so everyone has a counselor. Lucifer’s is a human who (for the first few seasons) has no idea Lucifer is, well, Lucifer. So she offers advice based on the human issues he’s discussing, including his problem with his father.

    When an angel-in-good-standing, Amenadiel (sp?) first arrives to take Lucifer back to Hell, there’s a lot of discussion of appointed roles vs. free will. For a goofy tv show, it covers a lot of ground.

  5. Don’t forget the later lines
    “Shouted out, who killed the Kennedys?
    When after all, it was you and me.”

    Telling us it’s too easy to shift the blame elsewhere.

  6. Yeah, the show seems like it challenges many of the preconceptions people have about the devil and the role Christianity has given him. Even when I was a firm believer I never took the theology involving Lucifer too seriously. I always saw his role as a scapegoat.

  7. Back to the point of this post; the song and the Rolling Stones:

    Back in the 1980s, before Country Music lost its mind, there were a number of really good country songs that crossed over. One I used to hear a lot on commercial, non-country radio was called “Kids of the Baby Boom” and had a lyric that went, “We had sympathy for the devil and the Rolling Stones”.

    As someone too young for the Baby Boom, I had sympathy for neither, because they were before my time. Mick Jagger was the gargoyle-looking dude singing with Jareth from Labyrinth about “Dancing in the Street”, LOL.

  8. So, I had to google who Jareth from the Labyrinth since I didn’t have a clue. Surprise! It was David Bowie. Now there’s an original rock icon that’s missed.

    Back in the early 80’s I was studying for the ministry in the heart of the Bible belt just south of Ft. Worth. At the time, no respectable theology student listened to country music, much less rock music. Only church ordained music could be enjoyed. (Amy Grant/ Second Chapter of Acts, Heritage Singers etc.) I didn’t even have a TV.

    But I do consider myself a serious musician (even though other’s might not.:) Last week I even did a show with a few friends at a nearby senior living home. The house was a rockin.

    A lot of musical genres took a turn for the worse in the 80’s. What I consider to be a turn for the worse is that music became very commercialized. Country music in particular with its nasal twang, country bumkin, pickup trucks and beer, broken relationships and faithful dogs image. These days you won’t hear a country music star sing about drink’n a Guinness beer or even a decent northwest IPA. It’s got to be a Bud or a Coors. Nor do country stars sing about driving Toyota or Honda Trucks. The trucks mentioned need to be Ford of Chevy’s so that the songs might be used in commercials on down the line.

    The advent of music videos probably had a lot to do with the degradation in the quality of music. When the marketability of a musician’s image became more important than the originality of music.

  9. I’m laughing because my college roommate in the early 1980s insisted there WAS no such thing as a “Christian singer”, just a singer who was Christian. And who was Christian? Only a very, very narrow of Southern Baptist born-agains.

    I miss the 1980s, when any random middle-of-the-road radio station would play a variety of artists from rock to heavy metal to pop to R&B to country. When country stars like Alabama, Juice Newton, Dolly Parton, Kenny Rogers, etc. ruled the air.

    After 9/11, country took a turn to the unlistenable “Gawd n guns n gunna kick yer a$$ if yew dun’t luuuuuv Jezuzzzzz” and I will never forgive country for giving us Taylor Swift.

    I bet you and your bandmates rocked the house down!

  10. Another note on Dolly Parton: accessible. Beautiful voice, variety of songs, and very welcoming to anyone who wants to be her fan. Gives out free books for kids, lets her father run that program because he never learned to read and it’s something he feels strongly about. Gave a million dollars to COVID research.

  11. We did rock the house . . . or was it rockin the rocking chairs? It was lots of fun and they really appreciated it. We even closed with the song Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen. Tell me that isn’t inclusive for an atheist to do!

    Saw Kenny R. at a state fair in San Antonio when he was still touring. And Dolly seems to be a wonderful person. I heard her mention one time about how it “takes a lot of money for her to look as cheap as she does!” Or something like that. Real down to earth. I recently saw her sing with one of my favorite female vocalists Brandi Carlile. Here’s one of her videos if you haven’t heard of her.

    https://youtu.be/BLgzxizPTzM

    I wasn’t really into country music growing up, but I went to a few special concerts like K.R., Willie Nelson, and Dwight Yoakum.

  12. I never went searching for country music, but it was all over the airwaves and much of it was fun. The Oak Ridge Boys had a song called Elvira that the local skating rink (Barbers Point!) used to play when I was in junior high, and all the kids would form a line and jump up and down to the “giddyap!” part.

    Willie Nelson had “On the Road Again” and sang with Julio Iglesias on “To All the Girls I’ve Loved Before” that were monster hits.

  13. I remember Elvira. I was still just a kid back then and mostly listened to music that my older brother was listening to like “Sugar, Sugar.” And a lot of other sappy music from bands like the Monkeys and the Loving Spoonfuls. I’m glad that by the time I hit high school some really good creative music was being recorded, which was right before music became really commercialized.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.