Unjust Judgment Concerning Caricature of Jesus

Unjust Judgment Concerning Caricature of Jesus October 19, 2018

By Nina Sankari

Statement of the Kazimierz Łyszczyński Foundation on the judgment concerning the caricature of Jesus in the weekly “NIE,” Kazimierz Łyszczyński Foundation, 2018-10-16.

The Kazimierz Łyszczynski Foundation and the Atheist Alliance of America express their outrage over the unjust judgment concerning publication of the caricature of Jesus in the weekly newspaper “NIE” (NO). The fine of 120,000 pln (more than USD $30,000) plus legal costs total 150,000 pln, which is many times higher than any fine ever ordered by a court for offending religious sentiments (article 196 of the Penal Code).

In 2015, by the request of the “blasphemer” Dorota Rabczewska (Doda), a similar case was examined against article 196 of the Penal Code. The interpretation given was that article 196 could be applied if the criticism of an object of religious worship was “abusive, derogatory and degrading.”

Taking this into consideration, this recent judgment’s reasoning is bizarre because this is a gentle cartoon depicting an amazed Jesus. Please look at it. It is in no way “abusive, derogatory and degrading.
The adoption of this law in 1997 was inconsistent with democracy, while its current application is a blatant mockery of democracy.

This is a political judgment which aims not only to condemn the independent satirical and anticlerical magazine to bankruptcy and to provoke a “chilling effect,” but it also seeks to intimidate both the media and society. We shall not let Polish law become an instrument of religious oppression, as is the case for the Shiite regime of the Ayatollahs or the Sunni theocracy in Saudi Arabia! We shall not allow the state authorities to put a death sentence on the freedom of the press by allowing them to act like those fundamentalists who attacked Charlie Hebdo!

Regardless of one’s sympathy or antipathy for Jerzy Urban and his weekly “NIE” we call for the defense of freedom of expression, freedom of conscience and freedom of the media because without them there is no democracy.

For more information regarding the Polish organization Fundacji im. Kazimierza Łyszczyńskiego, please visit www.lyszczynski.com.pl , or visit www.AtheistAllianceAmerica.org

Follow Mark W. Gura

Facebook: www.facebook.com/MarkWGura

Twitter: twitter.com/MarkWGura

Follow CW Brown

Facebook: www.facebook.com/CWBrown.PhilosophicalAtheism

Twitter: twitter.com/CW_Brown_

Follow Nina Rose Marina

Facebook: www.facebook.com/ninarose.marina.7

Follow  Nina Sankari

Facebook: www.facebook.com/nina.sankari

"Yes, of course humanity knows more about the nature of the universe today than we ..."

Where Life Came From
"Odd... You can't find a single instance where a "believing" person did anything "for" humanity? ..."

Aggressive vs. Passive Atheism
"I don't think I would tolerate working alongside someone like that for very long at ..."

Aggressive vs. Passive Atheism
"How about the god-botherer compromises and calls you a sinner deserving of eternal torture while ..."

Aggressive vs. Passive Atheism

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • wannabe

    This article would be greatly improved by having an introductory paragraph telling where the case occurred, with an outline of the facts. We also need a copy of the full caricature rather than the inset (for full context), and a label as to who the gentleman in the picture is.

  • zenlike

    I agree that this post merits some background, but disagree that a full caricature, even though it would be good to have here, is really that relevant to have, seeing how it sholdn’t matter in the least what and how the caricature is. Maybe they also decided not to include it to protect the posters against a similar lawsuit in Poland.

  • wannabe

    All right then, not a copy but at least a description. Jesus is looking amazed. What is he amazed at?