God cannot know he is omniscient

God cannot know he is omniscient March 20, 2013

Theists, the world over, claim that God is omniscient. However, this is not an easy claim to make for a whole host of reasons, one of which is worth looking into here. I want to look at the idea that in many instances, you cannot know that you don’t know something. If there is a situation where you cannot know something, then if it is claimed that you are omniscient, this would invalidate that claim.

For example, there could conceivably be something that God does not know. Conceivably, perhaps another dimension run by another God exists that does not coincide at all with this dimension. If one eternal God can exist, why not another in an entirely different dimension and unbeknownst to the first God? Now, it is unimportant as to whether this is possible or not. What is important is that God could not know that he did not know this by the very nature of not knowing it!

Where does this leave God? Well, God is in a situation whereby he cannot know that he knows everything. He might think he knows everything. Epistemologically speaking, though, he cannot know it. There’s always a chance he’s an experiment in an elaborate lab, programmed to think he’s omnipotent and omniscient (yes, God could be plugged into the Matrix and he’d never know it!). There’s a chance he’s one of a trillion gods in a trillion different universes, that he has himself been created by another, more powerful god, but that the other god made it so he was not aware of this etc. etc.

It only takes one thing you cannot know to invalidate omniscience. God cannot know that he knows everything.

"I remember when the polio vaccine came out and I don't remember anyone objecting back ..."

Talking with my taxi driver – ..."
"Not just state of health. There's the occasional biological oddball who is perfectly healthy but ..."

Talking with my taxi driver – ..."
"I concede there are risks with vaccines, my only point is with relatively normal people ..."

Talking with my taxi driver – ..."
"But we already know the answer to that question with respect to vaccines. The specifics ..."

Talking with my taxi driver – ..."

Browse Our Archives