Vatican suspends ‘bishop of bling’ Tebartz-van Elst

Vatican suspends ‘bishop of bling’ Tebartz-van Elst October 26, 2013

This one is from the BBC:


Residence of Limburg Bishop Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst, 17 Oct 13
Residence of Limburg Bishop Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst, 17 Oct 13
The bishop’s official residence in Limburg has been described as luxurious


The Vatican has suspended a senior German Church leader dubbed the “bishop of bling” by the media over his alleged lavish spending.

Bishop of Limburg Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst is accused of spending more than 31m euros (£26m; $42m) on renovating his official residence.

The Vatican said it deemed “appropriate… a period of leave from the diocese” for the bishop.

The suspension comes two days after he met the Pope to discuss the matter.

“A situation has been created in which the bishop can no longer exercise his episcopal duties”, a Vatican statement said.

It said a Church commission would rule on the matter, but did not say where Bishop Tebartz-van Elst, 53, would go or what he would do while the inquiry was held.

The head of Germany’s main lay Catholic group, the Central Committee of German Catholics, Alois Glueck, welcomed the Vatican’s decision.

He said: “Pope Francis’s decision offers the chance of a first step toward a new beginning in the Limburg diocese, because the situation has become an increasing burden for the faithful there, and in all of Germany, over recent weeks.”

Bishop Tebartz-van Elst – and his spending habits – had become infamous in Germany, where many people pay Church tax to the state. The tax raised 5.2bn euros for Catholics and 4.6bn euros for Protestants in 2012.

Calls were made for the bishop to resign after he was accused of lying under oath about his spending.

He was criticised for a first-class flight to India to visit the poor.

But his official residence is at the heart of the criticism, after renovations were originally costed at 5.5m euros.

German media are reporting that the residence was fitted with a bath that cost 15,000 euros, a conference table for 25,000 euros and a private chapel that cost 2.9m euros.

The story has attracted heavy coverage and has stoked controversy among Catholics.

It was in Germany that Martin Luther launched the Reformation five centuries ago in response to what he said were excesses and abuses within the Church.

The BBC’s Alan Johnston, in Rome, says all this was bound to play badly with the new Pope, who has repeatedly expressed his disapproval of senior clerics whose lifestyles seem a little too lavish.

Pope Francis has also signalled his intention to clean up the Vatican’s finances, appointing a commission to advise him on reforms.

There is no surprise in Rome that the Vatican has ordered the bishop’s suspension from his duties while the spending row is investigated, our correspondent adds.

Steffen Seibert, a spokesman for German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who is the daughter of a Protestant pastor, said that she had expressed “hope that there will be an answer for believers, for people’s confidence in their Church”.

In his absence, the bishop’s diocese will be administered by Limburg’s vicar general, Wolfgang Roesch.

"Wow, that's some list!. My daughter lived and worked in Botswana for nearly a year ..."

On God-Fearing Theists
""You cannot explain how life arose from non-life. You cannot explain how matter arose from ..."

Dems vs GOP: Voter Confidence in ..."
"Nobody disagrees that eugenics could be made to work.Clearly, you have not followed the discussion ..."

A Word That Everybody Hates
"Nobody disagrees that eugenics could be made to work. People have been breeding animals for ..."

A Word That Everybody Hates

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Peter

    Me thinks he’s just the first of many. Stupid man in this day in age did he not think some enterprising reporter would not find out? All the others out there must be shaking in there overpriced boots. Go, Francis, go.

    • I wonder if the new pope will shake it all up a bit. I wonder what many of the old school insiders think of him. There must be so many fascinating machinations in the Vatican.

      • Peter

        I fear for his safety because he is shaking up the old guard. Many have speculated and I often wondered if there is any truth to the rumour that the first John Paul was assassinated. Yes the Vatican is a Byzantine Palace with many following the dictates of Machiavelli: “the ends justify the means.” Like the Chinese proverb says we are living in interesting times.

    • Andy_Schueler

      Stupid man in this day in age did he not think some enterprising reporter would not find out?

      He made no efforts to hide his obscene spending, he just wasn´t worried that anyone might see anything wrong with that. The german dioceses are rich, and it is nothing unusual for german bishops to live a luxurious life while preaching the virtue of poverty (it is only a virtue for everyone else of course). Tebartz-van Elst was not qualitatively different from other german bishops, only quantitatively – he got so greedy that even his own flock couldn´t handle the breathtaking hypocrisy and wastefulness of his lifestyle.

      • Honest_John_Law

        It seems ironic that the Vatican would suspend a Church leader for displaying material wealth. The Vatican reportedly owns the most valuable private collection of artifacts on Earth. Some of its assets are so one-of-a-kind that it is difficult to assess how valuable they are.

        • This is a really vital point. Do you think Jesus would have held on to that wealth given all of the tirades he made against rich people? Of course not. That the Vatican itself has that much wealth is an insult to the tenets of the religion. Its very core values.

          • Honest_John_Law

            “Do you think Jesus would have held on to that wealth given all of the tirades he made against rich people?” – J.P.

            I don’t think Jesus, as characterized in scripture, would have accrued personal material wealth in the first place. What the Vatican owns is a powerful worldly display of the authority the Church held over the masses throughout many centuries.