The War Continues! Armstrong Tackles My Infancy Narrative Criticisms, and More

The War Continues! Armstrong Tackles My Infancy Narrative Criticisms, and More July 28, 2017

As many of you will know, Dave Armstrong, fellow Patheoser (of a Catholic persuasion) has been attempting to take me to task. It started off with criticising Anthony Toohey’s deconversion account, and then, springing from this, he looked at tackling claims that a detailed in my book The Nativity: A Critical Examination.

I won’t, here, rebut his claims – I have not yet read them – but feel free to do this yourselves until I get time to do so. Being exceptionally busy, I will struggle to do this in an adequately timely manner.

Here are his critiques:

As far as the infancy narrative rebuttals are concerned, I can’t imagine he will defer to the same old criticisms or defences that apologists have contrived over the last 1,500 years (i see from skimming one that this appears to be the case). Alas, this always seems to be the case, and we get possibiliter ergo probabiliter – or it’s possible, therefore it’s probable. Or, here is AN answer, therefore this answer defeats the counter-position.

We shall see.

Anyway, have at it.


In the meantime as well, please check my book above out.

"See my post in this thread. Her undercover media organization has been thoroughly discredited."

What’s The Deal With John Eastman?
"Can you admit that there are no coherent mathematical physics describing a living system to ..."

C Peterson on Quantum Indeterminacy
"Actually he's downplaying your fact free posts, 'supported' by links to RW hack sites and ..."

What’s The Deal With John Eastman?
"Well interesting, because it was Latimer who was black who made the lightbulb a practical ..."

Such Competence and Moral Integrity

Browse Our Archives