Multiverse or Cyclic Universe? Alan Guth vs Roger Penrose

Multiverse or Cyclic Universe? Alan Guth vs Roger Penrose September 4, 2021

Skydivephil (Phil Halper) has produced some amazing videos over the years, and this is no exception. It’s a real privilege to be able to see two of the biggest hitters in cosmology in conversation together. It’s a discussion between the father of inflationary cosmology, Alan Guth and 2020 Nobel Prize Winner in Physics Sir Roger Penrose. The debate is mostly cosmological but what should be of interest to the atheist community is that both quite clearly state that they don’t think the constants of nature are fine-tuned for life and both almost laugh at theologian William Lane Craig’s suggestion that infinity should be ruled out for the cosmos; they both agree the universe could be past eternal.

As Craig quotes both of these scientists to back up his views, I think it’s extremely interesting to see that not only do they not agree with him, but they don’t even think his ideas should be taken seriously. The relevant sections can be found here to those last few points: fine-tuning, multiverse: 59 mins infinity – 1 hour 24 mins. Also, about 11 mins – 12 mins.

Phil Halper does a great job of mediating the conversation. Good stuff.


Stay in touch! Like A Tippling Philosopher on Facebook:

A Tippling Philosopher

You can also buy me a cuppa. Or buy some of my awesome ATP merchandise! Please… It justifies me continuing to do this!

""At that point, we have handed our freedom – another important human good – over ..."

John King’s Admission on CNN
"More thn just a good feeling, public knowledge and recognition motivates change."

John King’s Admission on CNN
"Excerpts from a recent article titled Satan Loves “Safety”:“We all want to be physically safe, ..."

John King’s Admission on CNN
""Is it so hard to believe that the majority of a profession engages in that ..."

John King’s Admission on CNN

Browse Our Archives