Why Did Jesus Have to Rise?

Why Did Jesus Have to Rise? April 23, 2011

Brett Salkeld has posted very thoughtful reflection on atonement here and here.  At the risk of initiating a thread that Brett might himself have started, I’m offering these thoughts both in support of his reflections and as a way of following what appears to me to be a hint of God’s “Paschal logic.”

In a nutshell: Jesus enters the human drama where our sin leads us to kill people who don’t shoehorn themselves into our skewed view of justice.  He’s killed, as a just man.  God raises him to illustrate that we need fear death no more.  We who follow him, therefore, must follow that same compass of justice that will likely get us ostracized and maybe even killed.  But who cares?  God’s in charge and we’re more interested in justice than a temporary little pleasure like life.

A prolegomenon: I have a great reverence for Jewish tradition and dislike anything that smacks of supersessionism.  I don’t think Jesus or Paul invented a new religion.  I do think that Jesus was about calling Israel to its roots of radical obedience to the covenant with Abraham.  I do think Paul’s conversion had more to do with turning away from sin than turning away from the Jews.

Why did Jesus have to rise?  To show sinful humanity that death need not be feared.  Israel knew how to obey God, but succumbed (as we all still do) to the temptation to hitch their horses to limited human understandings of the good.  People were afraid to follow the law because, like us, they believed that only suckers follow the law.  Jesus’ teachings about radical love–grace shot through everything–got him killed because the Powers and Principalities simply couldn’t tolerate that kind of upsetting of things.  (Powerful people are the ones responsible for these limited versions of justice and therefore have the most to lose when prophets remind them how limited they are.)  Jesus died because he lived among people who kill.  Jesus rose because God is more powerful than people who kill.

Salvation, then: imagine having all your debt wiped away instantly.  Student loans, mortgages, car payments, credit card bills, everything.  You’re free.  That happens only if, in an instant, you no longer feel beholden to those powers who hold you in thrall–even better, if you learn that those powers no longer exist.

What Jesus did is accomplish that re-ordering of who’s in thrall to whom.  We are no longer in thrall to death, because Jesus showed us that it’s nothing to fear.  We’re no longer in thrall to sin, because we can (if we choose) reject every form of temptation to sin because we know those limited views of justice are weak candles against the Sun of God.  He set us free from our thrall: “for freedom Christ set us free.”  What human beings choose to do with our freedom begins the story of the Church.

Tim Muldoon is a theologian and author of five books, and teaches in the Honors Program at Boston College.

"Thank you for this honest and reflective article. You gave me lots to think about. ..."

If Christ is our only King
"Great Post, Jeannine. I, too, felt a lot of resonance."

If Christ is our only King
"I'm late seeing this, and I'm sorry for my prolonged absence here. But I want ..."

If Christ is our only King
"All the public information about Trump's plan indicates it would have been better. One reason ..."

A Lament for Afghanistan

Browse Our Archives