Progressive Christian Channel
Speaking Christian: An Interview with Marcus Borg
Marcus Borg's latest book, Speaking Christian: Why Christian Words Have Lost Their Meaning and Power-And How They Can Be Restored ranks with his earlier volumes, The Heart of Christianity and Embracing an Adult Faith, as efforts to renew and rebuild Christianity by healing long-standing wounds and welcoming millions of alienated men and women. David Crumm spoke to Borg about the challenges of "speaking Christian" and reviving the church.
"Sometimes words in the Bible are wrong." That's a dangerous thing for clergy to stand up and say in American churches, yet that's one of the main messages of your work.
I would love it if every clergyperson would stand up and say to their congregations: "Sometimes the Bible is wrong." There is a taken-for-grantedness in conservative American Christian culture—and it's true, I think, in much of mainline Christianity today as well—that understanding the Bible is simple. And, if the Bible says something is wrong, then that pretty much settles it. There are very few Christians who are willing to stand up and say, "Sometimes the Bible is wrong." Yet, I think that's really important for Christians to say occasionally.
Before some of our readers start throwing things at their computer screens, let's remind them that what you're saying actually makes a lot of common sense if we stop to think about the whole scope of the Bible.
Obvious examples are passages in the Bible that say slavery is OK. And, there are some passages in the Bible that absolutely prohibit divorce. In Mark 10:9, it's complete. Matthew has an exception clause: except for reasons of adultery. Then, there are clearly passages in the New Testament that expect Jesus to come again very soon from their point in time. Now, 2,000 years have passed. There are so many more examples where in plain terms we need to say, "Sometimes the Bible is wrong."
If people stop and think about this, down through history, they may recall examples in which people have done this. There were famous abolitionists who literally cut out the pro-slavery passages in their Bibles. Then there was Thomas Jefferson, who took a razor to his Bible and cut out passages that didn't make logical sense to him.
I think it's vitally important for people to talk about this in churches, but it's so difficult for clergy to do. And, in fundamentalist and conservative evangelical churches that affirm the sole authority of the Bible, that is very difficult for anyone to admit. It would startle most conservative congregations: "What do you mean the Bible is sometimes wrong? Where will our authority go if we start saying that?"
David Crumm is an author, journalist, and filmmaker with more than twenty years experience as a Religion Writer for the Detroit Free Press, Knight-Ridder newspapers, and Gannett. Crumm is now the Editor of ReadTheSpirit, a new online home for important voices in religion and spirituality.
You may also be interested in these stories:
- The Longing...for What? Reflections for the First Sunday of Advent: Isaiah 64:1-9
- On Recognizing the Shepherd: Reflections on Christ the King Sunday (Ezekiel 34:11-16, 20-24)
- Things Are Seldom What They Seem: Reflections on Judges 4:1-7
- Organ Donation, Persecuted Churches, Choice: Reflections on Joshua 24:1-3a, 14-25