“Credit” Is a Word Used to Exploit You: Step One in Economic Resistance

Lately I’ve been thinking more about social justice than about theology or philosophy or poetry. I am just as concerned as anyone else about our economic situation, caused by the greed, stupidity, and selfishness of the wealthy. They bully and exploit the other 98 percent of us with impunity, because our government, which they largely control, has stopped using the means provided by our laws to keep them from doing so. You cannot strike back by illegal means, for exactly the same reason that a child who is being bullied and who punches the bully is the one who is punished, unfair though that seems. However, there are ways to fight back, largely provided by civil law, IF. If, IF you realize you can. But often words you use embody assumptions that enable the unscrupulous to take unfair advantage of you. One such word is “credit.” (Others are “soul” and “heaven,” but that’s for a different discussion.)

I am temperamentally unsuited to be interested in accounting, but I have learned some of its basic concepts. One is the difference between a credit and a debit. In calculating one’s financial worth, one places money in hand and Accounts Receivable, which is money owed to you, in the Credit column. One places Accounts Payable, which is money you owe for products and services received, in the Debit column; then you subtract the latter from the former. So what is a “credit card”? Do you use it to acquire a credit? No, you use it to acquire a debt. Somehow the financial industry managed to turn the meaning of the word “credit” upside down. And what is a “credit rating”? Is it a measure of your financial worth? Some people seem to think so. Instead, it is a measure of how much debt you may be able to incur. In practice, it measures how high you rank on the Sucker List.

People who threaten to “ruin your credit rating” are bullying you and exploiting you. After all, are they threatening you with loss of income? Or with preventing you from getting what you need to survive with a decent quality of life? No, they are threatening to prevent you from going deeper into debt. Logically, you should thank them for that.

At one point, working on unlearning my addictive behavior patterns, I worked the Twelve Steps of Debtors Anonymous, in which one makes the decision not to acquire debt, one day at a time. In fact, I had the honor of bringing DA home from New York in 1983 and founding what I think was the very first DA meeting in California. You can live debt-free, just as you can refuse to ever take that first drink. What about bills, utilities and suchlike? Bills come with due dates, before which you do not actually owe the money. Only after the due date does the amount become a debt. If you arrange life so that you can pay all bills on time, you will be debt-free. Don’t make excuses about how difficult that would be. Don’t live in denial.

So you’re probably in debt. Most of us 98% are. You can get out of it. One strength of DA is educating its members in the basics of consumer law, about which most of us are abysmally ignorant. The exploiters like it that way. Another strength is that you can have a “pressure-relief group,” a small committee of peer advisors who serve to buffer you and take financial pressure off you by coming up with level-headed advice. You can choose some trusted friends to do that for you even outside of DA. If you have no such friends, then please admit how serious your life problems are.

The goal in DA is not to renege on your debts, but to pay them off; with some of these, like loans from friends, doing so is making amends. Other debts may be quite different ethically, such as ones you owe to business corporations and were inveigled into incurring by misrepresentation. The key fact we learn in DA is that YOU have the absolute right to decide how much to pay on any debt, NOT the creditor. If you make regular payments every month of any amount, even $5.00, the creditor must accept that and cannot sue you. Creditors will scream, complain, and make empty threats, but that’s all bluster. You have the right to meet your own real needs first.

Creditors will, of course, “ruin your credit rating,” which is a tool they own and use to exploit you. So what? If your goal is to live debt-free, they are threatening only to help you. What would you need “credit” for? Buying a car? Save up all the money you are not paying to creditors and buy a good used car for cash. An honest car dealer (and there are some) will happily sell you a car for the down payment plus what they could clear by selling your contract at a huge discount to a finance company; they’ll be glad to get their money upfront.

What about buying a house? Do you really need to? The American Dream of owning your own home is very much an unexamined assumption and, as is obvious, all too often leads to a nightmare. The latter is less likely if you can avoid acquiring a mortgage, the biggest debt most people face. Still, all those foreclosed houses are now available, real cheap. If you or, better, a small coop of trustworthy friends (I do hope you have some; this would be an excellent project for a real coven) have the discipline to save money for a few years, it is possible to buy a house for cash. Also, government financing does not depend on credit ratings. Still, paying rent may be a much better deal than taking on the burden of taxes, repairs, upkeep, and so on. Let the landlord who is in the business of buying and renting out houses pay for that overhead.

What most warms my socialist heart about the above is the possibility that, if enough people make the decision to turn their lives over to their Higher Power instead of to the 1 percent, the predatory lenders to whom billions of dollars in student loans are owed might get blown out of the water if their cash flow stops. I can hope. They deserve no pity. They are integral to the cabal that has destroyed free public higher education in America and is on the verge of destroying our educational system entirely. If you cut your payments down to what you can actually afford, they will make a deal to let you pay the loan off for pennies on the dollar; they will be desperate for cash.

I have other advice on how to defend yourself from the minions of the 1%. More will be revealed.



Trekking Toward Nineveh, Mile One
Prologue to a Story of Jesus and Mary
War Against Women: Empower the Victims
How I Pray
  • MeganIsHere

    Good luck getting a rented place without credit or with a poor credit rating. Unless you have a cosigner with good credit, you’ll be consigned to the worst housing available. When I rented a new apartment this year, I couldn’t put my live-in boyfriend on the application because he has no credit history, and I had to have relatives co-sign because of a defaulted student loan I paid off 2 years ago.

    I completely agree with you that the credit system is bullshit, but unfortunately right now the people most oppressed by it (poor-as-dirt folks) need to be taught to work within it, not avoid it altogether.

    • Robert Scott McKnight

      Actually, I agree with Aiden. Being taught to not play the game is the only way forward. Working in the financial system for 17 years now, I can tell you the game is rigged. There is no way for the poor to work within the system and win. The only hope is to change the rules. The only way that happens is by not playing by their rules. Yeah, it will hurt, but if our children are ever to have a chance of being anything other than serfs, we have to do this.

    • Asa

      I once had to ask one of my parents to co-sign a lease with me because of a $157 hospital bill that had gone to a collection agency several years earlier. To claim that ruining someone’s credit history is an empty threat just isn’t realistic.

  • Elizabeth Doxtator-Morenberg

    I work in retail, and I am having a bitch of a time trying to reconcile my aversion to credit to having to sell credit accounts to customers.

  • aidanakelly

    I am grateful for your comments. It is hard work to not play the credit game. As my creative writing mentor told us, if you join someone else’s game the fundamental rule is that they win. In order to win, you must invent your own game. And if you are a real mensch, you invent a game in which everyone wins. To start, however, I recommend working the Twelve Steps of Debtors Anonymous. You won’t be able to do that unless you are 100% certain that debt will kill you.