Troubling News about Incoming College Freshman

The Chicago Sun-Times’ front page story this morning is troubling to those of us who will be welcoming a new class of college freshman into our lecture halls in the next couple of weeks.

Three-quarters of them are not ready for university studies!

More than three-quarters of Illinois high school graduates aren’t completely ready for college, based on their ACT scores, state results of the college-admission test released Wednesday show.

Only 23 percent of Illinois’ 2011 high school graduating class — public and private — met college readiness standards in all four ACT subjects tested: English, reading, math and science.

There is a clear ethnic disparity here as the chart reveals. Although no group is extraordinary, in comparison there are significant disparities–especially among African Americans and Hispanics. I teach in an urban setting where the student population is quite ethnically diverse  with a large number of African American and Hispanic students. Among these ethnic groups only 4% and 9% respectively are prepared for college.

Everything Wrong with American Evangelical Civil Religion in one Picture
Gospel of the Lord Now Available in Logos
Regent Review of Mike Bird's Romans Commentary
Kavin Rowe's Review of John Barclay's Paul and the Gift
  • http://www.pillarontherock.com/ Chris Krycho

    Erm, that’s a pretty fundamental misuse of those statistics… 3/4 of high school graduates aren’t completely ready, sure. But the question isn’t high school graduates, it’s matriculating freshmen, and the study provides no relevant insight on that count.

    Certainly there’s still a problem, and the ethnic issues ought not be brushed over, but it’s always a bad idea to twist statistics to say something other than what they’re saying, and alarmism doesn’t help anyone.

    Best of luck with your new classes, though!

  • http://www.pillarontherock.com/ Chris Krycho

    Erm, that’s a pretty fundamental misuse of those statistics… 3/4 of high school graduates aren’t completely ready, sure. But the question isn’t high school graduates, it’s matriculating freshmen, and the study provides no relevant insight on that count.

    Certainly there’s still a problem, and the ethnic issues ought not be brushed over, but it’s always a bad idea to twist statistics to say something other than what they’re saying, and alarmism doesn’t help anyone.

    Best of luck with your new classes, though!


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X