Andreas Kostenberger Reviews Ehrman and Bird at TGC

Over at TGC, Andreas Kostenberger has reviews of both How Jesus Became God and How God Became Jesus. Good reviews.

He gives a good summary:

Jesus was not a mere man who only later became God; rather, God took on humanity in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. Within a short decade or two, the early Christians understood Jesus’ identity was intrinsic to the identity of Israel’s God and that he wasn’t a second or lesser god but instead part of God’s own being and identity and thus a fitting object of worship. Also, the types of Christology Ehrman discounts as contradictory are found side by side, even intertwined, in individual New Testament books like John and Colossians. Apparently, these biblical authors held both views simultaneously without considering them contradictory. This evidence calls into question Ehrman’s trajectory from exaltation to incarnation Christologies, then, as many New Testament authors would have to be internally conflicted for his thesis to be correct.

About our book, Kostenberger generously states:

All in all, the assessment of Ehrman’s work by this formidable phalanx of scholars is rather sobering. On a historical level, his arguments are refuted time and again, supported by compelling evidence. This carefully coordinated critique meets Ehrman, who presents himself first and foremost as a historian, at his own perceived area of greatest strength. On a theological level, Ehrman’s way of connecting the dots is exposed as a contrived exercise that has a degree of surface plausibility but evaporates upon closer historical scrutiny and a more balanced and comprehensive reading of all the relevant texts.

"'Paul did not realise how immoral slavery was'.- perhaps, but the author seems to be ..."

Scot McKnight on Colossians and Philemon
"Nice try. But since all of Jesus descendants on Mary's side were white ruddy with ..."

Was Jesus White? No, Way, He ..."
"How true you are Filip. Not to mention intelligent. But the bible also backs your ..."

Was Jesus White? No, Way, He ..."
"Right Kevin. And when the Jews brought your people over on the slave ships , ..."

Was Jesus White? No, Way, He ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Charles Breemer

    Damn, just how long are you going to be pimping this book here?

  • Patrick


    I’ve held that there is a “Jewish Trinity” in the OT. Not as obvious as the NT, but, it’s there. I’ve taken courses on the subject from Michael Heiser. Bart doesn’t seem to be aware of it.

    Daniel Boyarin sure has been ignored by Bart in his study on “The Jewish Christ” and he is not a believer. He demonstrates how 2cd temple Judaism definitely did have the “Christian antecedents” about Divine Messiah, trinity, etc.