In ExpTim 128.11 (2018) is a good exchange between Beverly Gaventa and John Barclay about Barclay’s book Paul and the Gift.
Gaventa’s critique includes:
– God’s gift includes the continuing beneficence of the giver to cause believers to endure.
– Paul is not concerned to fulfill some sort of ancient sense of moral order.
– Paul can talk about Jesus’ death in terms other than a gift.
– A neglect of the back end of Romans 8 concerning God’s triumph over the powers.
Barclay responds in his essay.