The Lure of Sithendom

In my last post I did not intend to suggest that one can make a facile equation between religious fundamentalists and the Sith. In fact, I think that the “religious Right” of our time has much in common with the Sith at their most sinister, and the Jedi at their most hypocritical.

In comparison with the Sith, recall how Palpatine used Anakin’s fear of death – the death of his beloved Padme – and of losing what he had. The desire to cheat death and the promise that this can be accomplished has been manipulated by lots of religious groups to win adherents. And when one throws in the promise of powerful miracles that will make your problems go away, you have not merely fundamentalism, but that of the televangelists whose Bibles apparently contain a misprint and say “Go, sell all you have and give to the rich”.

No religious tradition can avoid the potential for exclusivism that leads to fundamentalism of sorts. Anakin’s “If you’re not with me, you’re my enemy” sounds rather like the words attributed to Jesus, “Whoever is not with me is against me”. Yet elsewhere, Jesus is recorded as saying something much more inclusive: “Whoever is not against me is for me”. Trying to hold to both will simply have you running in circles. In the end, it may not be that goodness is self-authenticating as good, but that the struggle is to define as good that which is loving and selfless and kind, to define it as good first for ourselves, and then to seek to win others to that point of view. For as Obi-Wan said, much depends on one’s point of view.

As for the Jedi, they often traded in absolutes too. The dark side is too dangerous. Once you start down that path, it will forever control your destiny. It is not the Jedi way to kill prisoners. But Yoda’s words about the dark side proved false: one can come back. And when confronted with a dangerous Sith, Mace Windu was willing to cast aside principles and kill Palpatine.

There is nothing wrong with Christians having ideals that we regularly fail to attain. That is as it should be. It is when we pretend we achieve them and are judgmental on those who differ from us only in that they got caught that we become hypocrites, driving people to give up not only our hypocrisy but the ideals with it.

Luke Skywalker redefined the Jedi way. He “brought balance” (with his father’s help), finding that he could love and be attached, without sacrificing all his values and who he is in order to save his sister at any cost. That’s the great challenge: to not become what we are fighting against as we fight.

The greatest struggle is not to defeat evil. The greatest struggle is to hold to that which is pure and noble as good, and to not cast it aside in an attempt to defeat those who seem to have cast it aside themselves. For the challenge of our great epic stories – whether that of Jesus or that of Luke Skywalker – is to not repay evil for evil, but to overcome evil with good.

YouTube Preview Image

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/03089281236217906531 Scott F

    “The greatest struggle is not to defeat evil. The greatest struggle is to hold to that which is pure and noble as good”If only Darth Cheney had not turned to the dark side.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/07225890125470949454 Bad

    Have you ever read David Brin’s criticisms of Star Wars, particularly of the Dark Side stuff?It’s thought-provoking stuff, from how Lucas turned the force from a spiritual wisdom that anyone can learn (even Solo) to a sort of fascist birthright to the problem with Yoda. As you note, Yoda is pretty much nothing but wrong and useless. Luke goes to save his friends, and he doesn’t turn to the dark side but instead does a lot of good. And he finds out that Yoda and Kenobi have been lying to him. And the later movies basically reveal that Yoda was first laughably blind and then basically gives up on the entire galaxy after just ONE attempt to bring down the bad guys. At first it seems like raising the twins is part of some plan, but evidently not, because when Yoda complains that Luke is “too old” to train as a Jedi, whose fault is that? Yoda is the one who decided to go live in a swamp and not raise the twins as Jedis.The idea that somehow just getting angry at evil will make you evil has a kernel of truth to it, but it’s also a profoundly childish notion. Plenty of people fought Hitler, and hated him, without turning into Hitler.