If the Doctor met Jesus

I came across this image on a Christian meme Facebook page:

It had to get a mention here, since it brings religion and Doctor Who together. But I’m not impressed with what it does at the intersection.

If the Doctor were to encounter the historical Jesus, surely he would have been the Galilean exorcist, teacher, and/or Messianic claimant that historians find at the core of the Gospel narratives. Not a figure who speaks more directly with the later Christological claims of the church than even the Jesus of the Gospel of John (although falling backwards is reminiscent of what John alone depicts as happening in the Garden of Gethsemane). The historical Jesus didn’t cause people to fall over backwards in awe at his presence. He was clearly an thoroughly a human being.

If, on the other hand, the Doctor is here envisaged as encountering the exalted post-Easter Christ, then when and where is that supposed to be happening? Is the “right hand of God” a place that one can get with the TARDIS? And why does it have brick walls and ladders?

Imagining the Doctor encountering Jesus is a nice idea. But I think that it would make for a more interesting story, or meme image, if the figure of Jesus were treated with more seriousness and depth than this meme image does.

Because the truth is, for all its lofty language about Jesus, the image above treats Jesus very superficially. It is more concerned to heap on lofty titles, than to think either about historical realism or any serious theological considerations.

  • Nick

    Perhaps God, knowing that the Doctor was not from around there, decided to have Jesus mess with him a little :p

  • N8

    How would the Doctor NOT be aware of the impacts to Humanity that Jesus had?

    Sure, Jesus himself might not be aware of them, and would appear to anyone else as a fairly normal human, but the Doctor would know the history of Jesus.

    Timey-wimey-wibbly-wobbly.

  • beau_quilter

    Alternate universe, where every fundamental Christian notion is true.

  • Squid

    Surely in a sense, the Doctor is Jesus, or at least a sci-fi version of him? He’s always saving people and he’s prepared to die for them, and then there was that episode where he was resotored to power by the belief of the people of Earth, after Martha had walked around preaching his gospel. He’s even got a devillish counterpart in the Master. So Jesus might say to him ‘stop stealing my act’.

    On the other hand, the Doctor’s met a lot of so-called Gods already so he probably wouldn’t be all that impressed with title-dropping Jesus.

  • James Fujita

    John Hurt, who was Jesus in “History of the World: Part I,” will be playing a version of the Doctor in the upcoming “Doctor Who” anniversary special – which will feature both Matt Smith and David Tennant’s Doctors.

    So, the Doctor will meet Jesus, the Doctor will meet himself and the Doctor IS Jesus.

  • RiseOfTheEleventh

    Actually, the Doctor would be pleased to meet God, wouldn’t he?


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X