Mario Batali Tries to Live on Food Stamps

Doesn’t turn out so well.

The famous chef and his family tried living on $1.48 per meal for a week to draw attention to the need for food stamps in a hard-hit economy. How did that go, Mario?

“I’m (expletive deleted) starving,” said Batali, who’s on the board of the food relief agency Food Bank for New York City, which issued the challenge to celeb pals like Batali and anybody else who wants to know what it’s like.

Batali said his first reaction when asked to join was a big “gulp,” then he realized while shopping for Friday’s start of the challenge that with a little forethought it wouldn’t be all that brutal.

One lesson: forget organic and anything pesticide- or hormone-free. “The organic word slides out and saves you about 50 percent.”

So what’s on the Batali menu through Thursday? Lentil chili with onion, water and cumin was one dinner that came with a complaint from his wife when he bought two bags of lentils instead of one, until he convinced her the extra cost would mean cheap eats for the next day.

“Rice and beans is in my lunch every day,” Batali said. “We got a bag of mini gala apples for $3. We bought a pork shoulder roast for $8 and got two and a half meals out of it. I got a whole chicken for $5, but it was spoiled so I had to return it and got a $7 chicken instead. They were out of $5 chickens.”

Convenience also has been sacrificed, like the afternoon his boys, 14 and 15, were running late and the family really wanted to grab hot dogs before a basketball game but couldn’t.

His kids are doing well and didn’t have to be dragged into what Batali described as less of a publicity stunt and more of a conversation starter about what it means to be hungry in America today.

“They’re having more peanut butter and jelly than they’ve had in the last 10 years because bread is inexpensive and peanut butter and jelly, if you buy it at the right place at the right time, is cheap,” Batali said.

Also, the boys are eating school lunch, as those in low-income families do for free.

“Eating while poor” is not good for your health. People don’t eat at Micky-Ds because it’s good. Have you ever tasted that crap? You might as well eat the box. They eat there because it’s cheap, close, and easy, and when you don’t have a lot of money, sometimes that’s all you get. Same goes for a lot of cheap prepared foods that people buy with food stamps. Eating well on $1.48 a meal isn’t easy. As Batali observes, you can survive, but you can’t thrive.

Food stamps as part of the safety net are not a problem. (What is a problem is the 12 years of reckless fiscal policy that has driven our economy into the ditch and put so many people on food stamps who never would have been, but that’s another subject.) And while I appreciate Batali’s efforts here, many people on assistance supplement their EBT with food from other sources, such as churches, soup kitchens, and food banks.

The St. Vincent de Paul Society in particular does superb work at collecting and distributing food. Our SVDP pantry at church is always stocked and always giving out food. My father, 90 years old this year, volunteers at one church soup kitchen that feeds a couple hundred people every Thursday, with other churches and synagogues serving on the other days. (Yeah, I know: they’re just those wicked old god-botherers that so many of my brave combox commandos like to mock, yet oddly enough the local chapter of the Freedom From Religion Foundation aren’t part of the program.)

My point is this: federal foodstamp money is not the only solution to the hunger problem. We’re the solution. Matthew 25:35 and all that…

UPDATE: I’m not sure how I forgot this, but just last month my father’s soup kitchen (and all the others in New Jersey, as far as I know) were told they could no longer deliver meals to shut-ins because of health regulations. I’m reminded of all those stories of churches and other groups prohibited from serving the needy because they failed to meet some arcane regulations set by bureaucrats who have little contact with the needs and resources of real people.

Like Patheos Catholic on Facebook!


Emmaus Road Publishing & St. Paul Center Merge
Bishop Undergoes Amputation
A Newark School Changes Lives With the Rule of St. Benedict
Couple Uses Their Wedding Feast to Feed Refugees
About Thomas L. McDonald

Thomas L. McDonald writes about technology, theology, history, games, and shiny things. Details of his rather uneventful life as a professional writer and magazine editor can be found in the About tab.