Christian America?

Is America a “Christian nation”? A perennial puzzle, and finally impossible to answer without many “in what respects?” qualifiers.

One distinction might help: Presuppose a nation full of Christians, as America was for much of its history. That nation might take various forms, and the distinction I want to introduce is that between a biblical nation and a Christian nation.

A nation where the rite of royal anointing includes explicit references to the king’s iconic relation to the Anointed Jesus is (in that respect) Christian. A nation where the rite of inauguration includes an oath with a hand on a Bible, but includes no reference to Jesus or the Trinity or even God, may be a biblical nation but isn’t (in respect to this rite) a Christian policy.

Another example: Many American Puritan writers, and many American writers long after, considered America “God’s New Israel” (for a great selection from John Winthrop to Ralph Reed, see Conrad Cherry’s God’s New Israel: Religious Interpretations of American Destiny ). That is definitely a biblical trope. But it hardly qualifies as a Christian one, for it is self-evident in the New Testament that the church alone is God’s new Israel. Insofar as the American experience is read through the lends of America-as-Israel, America is a biblical but not a Christian nation.

"FYI our Uniting Church of Australia has its Pitt Street Uniting Church led by a ..."

Canon and Church
"I quite agree. But our knowledge of Jesus comes from the narrative traditions which were ..."

Canon and Church
"If God is indeed real and good then anyone whom does not teach good is ..."

Canon and Church
"Why use Paul (just some guy) as your measuring stick. His philosophy was entirely different ..."

Canon and Church

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!