Reconciling Reason and Faith

In Truth and Tolerance, Benedict XVI argues that the Western world is in a crisis that can only be solved if “reason and religion . . . come together again, without merging into each other” (144).

He insists this isn’t a matter of protecting the interests of religion, Rather, “it is for the sake of man and the world. And neither of them, it is clear, can be saved unless God reappears in a convincing fashion. No one can claim to be sure of the way to deal with this emergency. That is impossible, if only because in a free society truth can find no other way to prevail, and should seek no other way, than simply by the power of persuasion; yet persuasion can only be achieved with difficulty amid the multitude of pressures and demands to which people are subjected. We must venture an attempt to find the way, however, so as to make plausible once more, through various converging indications, something that for the most part lies far beyond the horizon of our own interests” (144).

I’d want to say that reason and religion are more intimately entwined than Benedict suggests. Reason functions only within traditions that have religious commitments of one sort or another. True reason depends on adherence to eternal reason, which is the eternal Logos, the Son of the heavenly Father.

Still, this is a rare combination: Realism about the depth of the cultural crisis that Europe faces, combined with confidence in the possibilities of persuasion and a forthright declaration that everything depends on God’s parousia.

"You're saying that Matthew isn't pointing back to Is. 7 as a prophecy claim that ..."

Fifth Gospel
"I don't think Matthew is presenting this as a miracle per se.His message for his ..."

Fifth Gospel
"I received visions for several years while using an over the counter dissociative medicine, Christ ..."

What Is Prophecy?
"But even if we say that the reference was to a real virgin (rather than ..."

Fifth Gospel

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • David Hume

    “Reason functions only within traditions that have religious commitments of one sort or another. ”

    rea·son

    ˈrēzən/Submit

    noun

    1.

    a cause, explanation, or justification for an action or event.

    “the minister resigned for personal reasons”

    synonyms: cause, ground(s), basis, rationale; More

    2.

    the power of the mind to think, understand, and form judgments by a process of logic.

    “there is a close connection between reason and emotion”

    synonyms: rationality, logic, logical thought, reasoning, cognition; formalratiocination

    “postmodern voices railing against reason”

    verb

    verb: reason; 3rd person present: reasons; past tense: reasoned; past participle: reasoned; gerund or present participle: reasoning

    1.

    think, understand, and form judgments by a process of logic.

    “humans do not reason entirely from facts”

    synonyms: think rationally, think logically, use one’s common sense, use one’s head/brain;”

    Sorry, but reason should be grounded in reality and logic, not religion.

  • Satanic_Panic

    Reason functions only within traditions that have religious commitments of one sort or another. True reason depends on adherence to eternal reason, which is the eternal Logos, the Son of the heavenly Father.

    These sentences mean less than nothing – simply bald assertions with no evidence and scant argumentation. What is “true reason”? How can I tell it from “not true reason”? How would you know if you were wrong about what “true reason” is?

    Reason functions only within traditions that have religious commitments of one sort or another. I have to highlight this “gem” in particular. What does this word salad mean? Are you suggesting that only religious people (all religious people? only those of your particular faith?) can have or usee “reason”? That is monstrously arrogant as well as being a non sequitur.