Why the Red Sox Always LOST the World Series

In the episode of LOST from season 1 entitled “Outlaws“, Sawyer meets Christian Shepherd in a bar in Australia. Christian tells Sawyer that he is too weak to do that which could fix everything – call his son and tell him that he loves him, and that he’s grateful and proud because of what he did, rather than feeling betrayed. Christian talks about fate, and we learn that he had a saying, “That’s why the Red Sox will never win the World Series”.

As we’ve witnessed Christian Shepherd take on some rather startling qualities on the island since then, and become somehow interconnected with the island, we must ask the question: was Christian Shepherd somehow involved with the island, whether the “Others” or the Dharma Initiative? Was he involved in time travel? When he spoke of fate, did he really mean a future that he knew about and thus considered inevitable?

What was his role in getting not only Claire but also Jack and his own corpse on the plane that was “fated” to crash on the island?

What’s most interesting is that Ben later shows Jack a video of the Red Sox winning the World Series. The most recent Dharma Initiative film suggests that some think the future can be changed. Perhaps the universe does indeed have a way of “course correcting”, but if one makes a significant enough change at a significant enough juncture in history, then it produces an effect to large to be corrected for. Perhaps it is possible to change the past – and the future.

There’s a nice summary of the episode on the Houston Chronicle’s Tubular blog.

"I think your first point is either spot on or seriously troubling, depending on your ..."

#CFP Diversity in the Religion Classroom
"For what it is worth, I have always held a most deep philosophic and logical ..."

#CFP Diversity in the Religion Classroom
"The best clue, they were written in Greek. Not implying that there wasn’t a thread ..."

New Age Translation of the Lord’s ..."
"Once again you are trying to argue in a circle - assuming that Jesus is ..."

What Does The Bible Literally Say?

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/05283809456471966882 Bill

    Okay, now you’ve got ME thinking! CS indirectly helped get Anna on that particular plane, too, because of the timing. (And did you see the verizon short a year ago, with CS overlooking the original crash, petting Vincent?)Only question is, if CS was already aware of things to come, as you say, did he “fake” is own death? For that matter, we don’t know yet how he died, do we? Ooh. CS flashback coming! Waitforit. :)

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/02561146722461747647 James F. McGrath

    Have we been told definitively that Christian Shepherd is really dead? Could he have faked his death, knowing that his son would be too grieved to question that the body of his father in the morgue, with the doctor mentioning his blood alcohol level, was really dead? After all, if he was simply living on as a spirit or as a manifestation of the island, then why was his body missing from the coffin? At first glance, the fact that he seems able to appear and disappear from all sorts of places might seem definitive. But we’ve seen the Others do that, and they aren’t all dead.Or are they…? :)