Religion Prof: The Blog of James F. McGrath
The Blog of Dr. James F. McGrath, Clarence L. Goodwin Chair in New Testament Language and Literature at Butler University, Indianapolis
By Adele Lorienne, via Tumblr and Pinterest. Click through to see some of this artist’s other lovely works of Doctor Who fan art. My response to the above is this:
The last cartoon raises once again all those old questions about why they don’t just fly to Mordor on giant eagles…
“Why is this always brought up?
It’s because the Eagles did not want to be involved; they were neutral and didn’t want to have to choose sides. The only reason they helped Sam and Frodo at the end of RotK is because of Gandalf’s relationship with the Eagles. Radagast was a huge influence, too. Still can’t believe Peter Jackson left out so much shit in those films.
Oh, and not to mention the fact those Nazgul would’ve torn the eagles to shreds as soon as Sauron saw them. Which, he’d be able to see them from miles away. Hundreds of miles away, especially if the Fellowship riding horses got his attention.”
On this occasion it was brought up because the cartoon reminds me of the argument about the eagles.
That seems like a good enough reason to mention it to me — don’t you agree?
Why do people always jump to the defense of Tolkien when there’s the faintest whiff of criticism? :-]
(I didn’t say I *agreed* with those arguments…)
And here’s another response: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/religionprof/2013/01/one-does-not-simply-vworp-into-mordor.html
“One does not simply ‘vworp’ into Mordor.”
Sign up for free newsletters and special offers
Follow Patheos on