Agnostic Theists and Other Varieties

Agnostic Theists and Other Varieties

I came across this image today on Reddit:

It poses two axes, knowledge and belief. But one of them strikes me as peculiar. Why is the one that runs from left to right categorized as having to do with โ€œbeliefโ€?

It seems to me that a graphic that explores religious and non-religious options, and the relative sense of certainty adherents to them have, could be useful. The โ€œknowledgeโ€ axis is clearly about confidence in oneโ€™s views and not โ€œknowledge.โ€

And of course, โ€œGnosticโ€ has other connotations.

It is presumably an attempt to improve on the linear Dawkins Scale which I blogged about previously. But it is just as problematic, if not more so.

Has anyone seen a diagram like this, but one which deals with the varieties of religious and areligious confidence in a better way?


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!