Modern Christianity’s Most Underrated Book

Modern Christianity’s Most Underrated Book March 20, 2018

In the 1700’s, there was a book published that produced a ripple-like effect of evangelism that could be felt for centuries. It has inspired countless missionaries to persevere through intense adversity, for the sake of bringing the gospel to the lost. It’s a brilliant book that is as equally compelling as it is eloquent. Yet sadly, it is rarely spoken of by modern-day Christians; if nothing changes, I fear an entire generation may miss out on a classic.

The book I speak of is The Life and Diary of David Brainerd by Jonathan Edwards.

You might be surprised to learn that despite Edwards’ many works, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd is his most reprinted. In fact, it has never been out of print since it was originally published in 1749. Still, you are 10 times more likely to overhear strangers in a coffee shop discussing the latest Rob Bell book than this one. While few would contend against its rightful place among other Christian classics, it may be the most under appreciated book in western Christianity today.

For many notable Christians such as John Wesley, Jim Elliott, and William Carry, the work has served as something of a pocket-guide for missionaries and/or men pursuing formal ministry. It’s a book that masterfully deals with the sufferings and struggles one experiences as a missionary. In raw honesty, it details moments of perseverance, prayer, depression, joy, and grace. Theologian John Piper once said that he speculates the modern missionary movement wouldn’t even exist today if it had not been for The Life and Diary of David Brainerd. It’s that important.

Who was David Brainerd? What makes his life and diary so special?

David Brainerd

David Brainerd was a seminary dropout (not by choice) who had a passion for winning souls to Christ. After being kicked out of Yale for smarting-off to a professor (something he came to regret later in life), he became a missionary to the Native Americans in what is now the north-eastern United States. He dedicated what remained of his life to these people.

Mr. Brainerd was a missionary for only 4 years and a Christian for a total of 8; he died when he was 29 years old. Brainerd is a reminder of how a short life, when dedicated to Christ, can have a profound influence on our world. God’s plan for Brainerd far exceeded the Native Americans he would personally encounter. His honesty, insight, and struggles have been an inspiration for an untold number of Christians ever since.

It was during this season of missionary work that Mr. Brainerd became close friends with famous theologian, Jonathan Edwards, and his family. So close, in fact, that when David became very ill in the final year of his life, he sought refuge in the Edwards’ home. He was cared for by Jurusha, Jonathan Edwards’ daughter, until his death in 1747. She died not long after David due to the same ailment, tuberculosis. Likely, it was David who infected her.

Despite losing his daughter in such a terrible way, Jonathan Edwards was nothing short of thankful that Mr. Brainerd came to his home. Edwards offers the following commentary on this experience:

“I would conclude my observations on the merciful circumstances of Mr. Brainerd’s death without acknowledging with thankfulness the gracious dispensation of Providence to me and my family in so ordering that he … should be cast hither to my house, in his last sickness, and should die here: so that we had opportunity for much acquaintance and conversation with him, and to show him kindness in such circumstances, and to see his dying behavior, to hear his dying speeches, to receive his dying counsels, and to have the benefit of his dying prayers” (pg. 306, Reflections on the Life of Mr. Brainerd),

In Brainerd’s diary, compiled by Edwards after his death, we learn of his extreme physical and spiritual struggles. He records bouts of intense depression, constant sickness, devastating feelings of isolation, and various other adversities. He dissects the human heart like a surgeon and finds ways to articulate groanings of the heart that are often difficult to capture with words. More than once I have read from Brainerd’s journal entries and exclaimed out loud: “Yes! I have felt that too!”

Studying Brainerd’s sufferings serve as a refreshingly honest take on the Christian life, and more specifically, the life of a missionary. It is a far cry from the “Your Best Life Now” genre of Christianity so prevalent in today’s western thought. The Christian experience was never intended to be easy and prosperous. Instead, it’s laden with promises of hardships and persecutions (1 Timothy 3:12). The focus must not be on this vapor of a life, but on the eternal one found only in Christ. Brainerd’s struggles to keep his afflictions in perspective of the eternal treasure of Christ Jesus is a message our generation deeply needs.

Consider the following words from Brainerd as he discusses the natural hardships of missionary work:

“Such fatigues and hardship as these serve to wean me more from the earth; and, I trust, will make heaven the sweeter. Formerly, when I was thus exposed to cold, rain, etc., I was ready to please myself with the thoughts of enjoying a comfortable house, a warm fire, and other outward comforts; but now these have less place in my heart (through the grace of God) and my eye is more to God for comfort. In this world, I expect tribulation; and it does not now, as formerly, appear strange to me; I don’t in such seasons of difficulty flatter myself that it will be better hereafter; but rather think how much worse it might be; how much greater trials others of God’s children have endured; and how much greater are yet perhaps reserved for me. Blessed be God that he is the comfort to me, under my sharpest trials; and scarce ever lets these thoughts be attended with terror or melancholy; but they are attended frequently with great joy (p. 274).”

This mature, Christian worldview would not be possible unless David Brainerd were thoroughly aware of his sinfulness and desperate need for forgiveness. He regularly documents his wicked heart and repeatedly refers to himself as a worm before the holy God. He writes, “I saw so much of the wickedness of my heart that I longed to get away from myself…I felt almost pressed to death with my own vileness. Oh, what a body of death is there in me…Oh the closest walk with God is the sweetest heaven that can be enjoyed on earth!” (pg. 63)

Far too many Christians today are more concerned with being entertained than exploring the depths of their own sinful hearts. However, this is what Brainerd reminds us over and over that we must do – regardless of the cost. If we are to find wonderful communion with Christ, it will happen by means of prayer, contemplation, and the meditation of scripture. Our estate is fatally flawed, yet grace is overflowing for those who seek it.

I encourage anyone who has never read The Life and Diary of David Brainerd to find a copy, read it, and share it with someone else. It’s a book with a message that an entire generation of Christians needs to hear. My plea to read this book feels especially urgent as our culture continues to grow more hostile towards Christianity and ideals.  Persecution and suffering are coming; Indeed, it is promised for all who desire to live a godly life.

In closing, I will leave you with  one of my favorite quotes from the book – Brainerd’s description of his conversion experience, dated July 12, 1739:

One morning, while I was walking in a solitary place, as usual, I at once saw that all my contrivances and projects to effect or procure deliverance and salvation for myself, were utterly in vain; I was brought quite to a stand, as finding myself totally lost…

(Then) unspeakable glory seemed to open to the view and apprehension of my soul.  It was a new inward apprehension or view that I had of God, such as I never had before, nor any thing which had the least resemblance of it. I stood still, wondered, and admired! I knew that I never had seen before anything comparable to it for excellency and beauty; it was widely different from all the conceptions that ever I had of God, or things divine.

My soul rejoiced with joy unspeakable, to see such a God, such a glorious Divine Being; and I was inwardly pleased and satisfied that he should be God over all for ever and ever. My soul was so captivated and delighted with the excellency, loveliness, greatness, and other perfections of God, that I was even swallowed up in him; at least to that degree, that I had no thought (as I remember) at first about my own salvation, and scarce reflected there was such a creature as myself (Pg. 13).



"In Comes Pastor David once again with a message of faith to his followers!Yes, because ..."

Steven Furtick is the Most Dangerous ..."
"You claim to have 'been there and done that' (no tee shirt?), which means, if ..."

Steven Furtick is the Most Dangerous ..."
"Yep. Been there. Done that. I guess you just want me to take you on ..."

Steven Furtick is the Most Dangerous ..."
"I have no intention of delving into the labyrinthine thinking of the Scholastics just to ..."

Steven Furtick is the Most Dangerous ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Salvatore Anthony Luiso

    The Life and Diary of David Brainerd is an outstanding book. If I remember correctly, I read in A History of Christian Missions, by Stephen Neill (second edition edited by Owen Chadwick) that for one-hundred years it was packed in the suitcase of every missionary.

    Maybe you should write a series of articles based on passages of his diary? If you do, I suggest you decide how you want to refer to Brainerd. In this article, you refer to him three times as “David Brainard”, two times as “Mr. Brainerd”, once as “Mr. Brainard”, twice as “Brainard”, and three times as “David”. (Notice that his last name is spelled with three different vowels, not just two.)

    Also: It looks like you wanted to post a picture of Brainerd with your article, but it isn’t visible.

    It is remarkable that a young man who was expelled from a seminary subsequently attained a reputation as high was that of Brainerd–and that through less than ten additional years of life in this world. That incident, and the situation in which it occurred, is itself worthy of an article.

    • Jack Lee

      It is incredible how God used his short life. His journal has been inspiration to me for many years (and I know countless others). Thanks for reading and commenting.

      Wow – thanks for making aware of the name typos; as soon as the server updates, they will be corrected. I felt I was battling a mental block the entire time – haha. The picture comes up on my end no problem – not sure on that one.

      Thanks again!

      • Salvatore Anthony Luiso

        You’re welcome. I can see the picture of Brainerd now.

        You may be interested to know that The Banner of Truth Trust not only publishes The Life and Diary of David Brainerd and other books which tell about Brainerd, but has a website with dozens of articles that are either about or at least mention him. One can find them easily by going to Banner’s website and searching on his name.

        • Jack Lee

          Thanks for the recommendation!

  • Eileen

    Just bought the book online. Thanks for the recommendation!

    • Jack Lee

      Let us know what you think!

      • Eileen

        Hi. I’m about 100 pages into it. I also recommended it to a friend of mine who is a missionary to Uganda. We both have had the same response. I’ve never read anything (thus far) so depressing in regard to one’s Christian faith in my life. My missionary friend has had the exact same response. She skipped ahead to the end because she couldn’t bring herself to continue, and she is the bravest woman I know, going into some of the darkest, most oppressed parts of Africa to share the gospel.

        I am reluctant to continue reading. While I admire this man’s commitment to the Lord even in the face of such drastic spiritual conflict, I’m just not sure I can take an entire book-worth of this. It must be worth continuing or it wouldn’t be so highly recommended. Help me out here. My friend and I can’t be the only ones with this response. Thanks!

        • Jack Lee

          Eileen, thanks for the follow up! It is a tough read at times. I think for many, myself included, it’s perseverance throughs such trials that inspires. Despite physical, emotional, or mental ailments he pushes on and seeks after Christ. Its the insight into the heart and his willingness to lay down anything for Christ that makes the book memorable. I’m not sure if that helps, or makes it easier to read.

    • Eileen

      Oops! Responded to myself by accident. See my comments below.

  • Alan Drake

    I thought this essay was going to be about “The Journal of John Woolman”, in print since 1774.

    His personal struggle towards Truth is noteworthy.

    John Woolman lit the spark that lead to the world-wide abolition of legal slavery. His views on many other issues (Native Americans, animal cruelty, occupational poisoning, etc) also reflected the Light of God.

    Another Christian classic !