“The Jenkins Follies: Nahom and the Strawman Fallacy”

“The Jenkins Follies: Nahom and the Strawman Fallacy” July 15, 2015

 

Lehi's Bountiful?
A scene at Wadi Sayq
From the Ministry of Tourism of the Sultanate of Oman

 

Back on 1 July, on his interesting blog called “The Blade of Averroes,” Pedro Olavarria offered a helpful summation of the actual issues involved with NHM/Nahom and, along the way, illustrated how very poorly Phillip Jenkins has been handling the Book of Mormon in his now lengthy series of blogged attack-posts on the topic:

 

http://averroes2.blogspot.com/2015/07/the-jenkins-follies-nahom-and-starwman.html

 

I must admit that I’ve been very disappointed in Professor Jenkins, on several levels.

 

For instance, Wadi Sayq, as a likely candidate for Lehi’s Old World “Bountiful,” is part of the case regarding Nahom/NHM.  However, Dr. Jenkins doesn’t mention that — perhaps, and this is the charitable explanation, because he’s completely unaware of it.

 

I’m mystified by the dogmatic stance that he’s taken, given the fact that he hasn’t read much, refuses to read, and doesn’t know much.  It’s been somewhat embarrassing, from my point of view.

 

I didn’t expect him to convert.  But I’m surprised at his curious combination of hostility and ignorance.  It’s unbecoming of a scholar.

 

Posted from Santa Fe, New Mexico

 

 

"SGDN: "If you have 5 minutes I can help you resolve this issue once and ..."

Thoughts on a few controversial topics ..."
"No, not all of them. Just the few with the bone saws."

Thoughts on a few controversial topics ..."
"Eugene Clark had a profound influence on my life as well. He was indeed a ..."

Mother Earth and I
"There are certainly a lot of things that we can sense subconsciously or unconsciously."

Thoughts on a few controversial topics ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Mormon
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment