Semitic and Egyptian influences in Amerindian languages?

Semitic and Egyptian influences in Amerindian languages? December 18, 2016


Ecclesiastes 3 in Hebrew
A Hebrew Bible opened to Ecclesiastes 3  (Wikimedia Commons)


I’ve posted before — here and here — about the exciting, innovative, and potentially explosive work of Brian Stubbs, in which he argues for the presence of ancient Semitic and Egyptian influences in the languages of the Uto-Aztecan family.


Since I’m not an expert historical/comparative Semitic linguist and know nothing whatever about Uto-Aztecan languages, I’ve been eager to know what people with relevant training and background might have to say about his research.  I’m delighted, accordingly, to see a new review in BYU Studies:


“Exploring the Explanatory Power of Semitic and Egyptian in Uto-Aztecan”


The implications of this work for the background plausibility of the Book of Mormon should, as I’ve observed, be obvious.  If Brian Stubbs is wrong, it doesn’t much affect the case for the Book of Mormon since few if any of us expected Semitic and/or Egyptian elements in Uto-Aztecan in the first place.  But if he’s right, it will demonstrate beyond reasonable question that there were Pre-Columbian contacts of some substantial sort between peoples of the Americas and peoples of the ancient Middle East.


However, even if the claims of the Book of Mormon are bracketed, this is really interesting stuff.


Posted from Richmond, Virginia



"Except the fake doctors weren’t banned here but instead took their marbles and went home, ..."

John Gee on the recent Joseph ..."
"The short answer is that's personal. One of the editors of the JSP volume doesn't ..."

John Gee on the recent Joseph ..."
"Wrapture, thank you for pointing out the typographical error in my previous reply. I have ..."

Science and Wissenschaft (A)
"Oh, noes! It "describes religious thought much more so than any science [you've] sever seen" ..."

Science and Wissenschaft (A)

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment