Wisdom from the first Islamic caliph

Wisdom from the first Islamic caliph May 25, 2018


‘Umar at Jerusalem
An anonymous nineteenth-century illustration of the AD 638 conquest of Jerusalem by ‘Umar, the second Islamic caliph or successor to Muhammad.  (Wikimedia Commons public domain)


I related this story to each of the three groups that I’ve recently led around Jerusalem and Israel:


Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, died unexpectedly and rather suddenly in 632 A.D., after only a brief illness.


When the news reached ‘Umar that Muhammad was gone, that strong man, who would later rule over the entire Islamic empire as the second successor, or caliph, to the Prophet, seems to have become virtually hysterical.  (Muhammad’s death must have been utterly devastating to the earliest Muslims.)  He stood among the people and cried out that Muhammad was not dead, that he had merely gone to the Lord for a brief time (presumably in an ascension to heaven like the celebrated mi‘raj from the Temple Mount in Jerusalem).  After forty days, ‘Umar declared, the Prophet would return, and he would punish those who had falsely proclaimed his death.


However, Abu Bakr, an older man who would soon emerge as Muhammad’s first successor, heard the commotion and, determined to ascertain the truth, went into the house where the body of the Prophet lay.  He uncovered Muhammad’s face and kissed it, saying, “You are dearer [to me] than my father and mother.  You have tasted the death that God had decreed; a second death will never overtake you.”  Then he covered the Prophet’s face again and went out.


‘Umar was still manically denying Muhammad’s death outside of the mosque.


“Gently, ‘Umar,” Abu Bakr whispered to his younger associate.  “Be quiet.”


But ‘Umar continued to cry out.


Finally, standing up, putting his arm around ‘Umar’s shoulders, and addressing the bystanders, Abu Bakr said, “O men, if anyone worships Muhammad, Muhammad is dead.  If anyone worships God, God is alive and cannot die.”


Then he recited a passage from the Qur’an (38:31):


“Muhammad is nothing but a messenger; messengers have passed away before him.  Why, if he should die or be killed, will you turn about on your heels?  If any man should turn about on his heels, he will not harm God in any way, and God will reward the grateful.”


I think that there is enormous wisdom in those words:  “If anyone worships Muhammad, Muhammad is dead.  If anyone worships God, God is alive and cannot die.”


Men fail, fade, die.  Even great ones.  As Nephi says, we should not rely upon “the arm of flesh.”


Posted from Jerusalem, Israel



"I, personally, appreciated being able to read about the fire victims, and know a bit ..."

The Church does good around the ..."
"My appologies. I thought we were talking about evidence, which implies a framework of rationality ..."

“I knew I was dying now”
"When we unplug a radio, the radio stops. Do we conclude that electricity is necessary ..."

“I knew I was dying now”
"Oh come now, Dr. Peterson, you are among friends. So, where did you hide the ..."

The Church does good around the ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment