Paul on Sin in Romans 5-6

Paul on Sin in Romans 5-6 February 6, 2014

For Paul, “sin” is not just behavior, but more akin to force and dark power that holds sway over people.

While the doctrine of “original sin” gets a hard time (I prefer talking about original “guilt” and original “death”), G.K. Chesteron famously said, original sin is the only Christian doctrine that is empirically verifiable. All people sin. All people imitate sin. All people have a propensity to sin. All people are guilty of sin. That human beings sin, transgress, break laws, violate rights, and commit immoral deeds is self-evident to everyone. I have to confess that one of the things that amazed me as a parent was that I never had to teach my children how to lie. They picked it up quite naturally. The mess that one child makes he or she will instinctively blame on another child, preferably the younger one, who cannot yet speak for themselves. Greed, violence, and selfishness seem like the default setting that they are born with. I sincerely believe that crying babies would throw their own mothers under a truck if it would get them what they want. Experience has also taught me that raising toddlers is like working for Caligula and Charlie Sheen combined. A house run by teenage boys has about the same degree of law and order as lunatics running an asylum. A colony of minors stranded on an island would not resemble Peter Pan’s paradisiac Never Never Land, but would descend immediately into violence and terror more akin to William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies where the strongest ruled the weakest with merciless spite. If you ever want to see what people are like, what they are truly like, see what they do when they think no one is watching them. Whether it is under a hoody, in a dark alley, or anonymously on the internet, that is when you see what evil desires and what dark proclivities lurk within the hearts of men and women. I’m sure psychologists, sociologists, and anthropologists have their own models and explanation for this sort of innately inhumane behavior, but just as equally important is the theological one: human beings are born into the world with an inherent propensity to sin because they are born into the world separated from God. The whole condition of guilt, sinful behavior, and death is all traceable to the one act of disobedience in our primeval parents, Adam and Eve.

The story narrated in Rom 5:12-21 is that God’s grace is greater than all our sin. Whatever Adam had done is matched by the how much more Christ has done for us. The death, condemnation, and corruption introduced with Adam is reversed and surpassed by the grace and gift available in the Lord Jesus. The German tennis player Boris Becker said that when playing his absolute best that he could theoretically beat American Pete Sampras. But he also said that if he played his best and if Sampras played his best, Sampras was always going to win, because his best was always better. If sin is Becker then grace is Sampras. Grace is always gonna win!

Coming to Rom 6:1-2 (“What shall we say, then? Shall we go on sinning so that grace may increase?  By no means! We are those who have died to sin; how can we live in it any longer?”) what Paul means by “sin” is a cross between a status, a state, and servitude. To put it another way, it is like he is asking whether believers think that, because they can drink from an overflowing fountain of divine grace, they can just hang up their hammocks and remain contented where they are despite the fact that they are in the middle of the Gobi desert where North African slave traders are likely to capture them and sell them into slavery. Grace is designed to get them out of that situation, not to make them feel more comfortable within it. Instead of living in Sin-land they can live in Graceland (complete with Elvis memorabilia).

The solution to sin is the Messiah’s death and resurrection which creates ethical imperatives by sharing in its transformative work. Or, as N.T. Wright comments on Rom 6:4: “The Messiah’s resurrection means that those who are ‘in the Messiah’ now stand, and must walk, on resurrection ground.”

"How did this book reinforce or challenge your theology?"

Reading Christian Theology in the Protestant ..."
"I'm not familiar with David nor have I read his book though I hope to ..."

A War of Loves – The ..."
"My wife and I attended our first Holy Week vigil at a local Roman Catholic ..."

Flemming Rutlege on Good Friday
"The Holy Gospels of Our Lord are 'testaments' to Him, to His teachings, to how ..."

Why Were the Gospels Written?

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • There has never been a human society consisting of only adolescent males as depicted in the fictional “Lord of the Flies,” yet it is referenced as if it was some factual anthropological study.

    As to sin and real anthropological studies, let’s look at a genuinely scientific study, and an interpretation of “sin” based on fact, as follows:

    1. Is it natural for humans to make war? New study of tribal societies reveals conflict is an alien concept

    2. Ched Myers (2005) The Fall. Encyclopedia of Religion and Nature. Edited by Bron Taylor. NY: Continuum.

    The best interpretation of “Original Sin” I’ve seen is that The Fall, as Ched Myers asserts, is equivalent to Jared Diamond’s “worst mistake in the history of the human race.”

    “…we chose the latter [agriculture] and ended up with starvation, warfare, and tyranny.” ~Jared Diamond (May 1987) The Worst Mistake In The History Of The Human Race. Discover Magazine. pp. 64-66.

    • Lamont

      I didn’t see any reference to “war?”
      He said in his reference to Lord Of The Flies: “A colony of minors stranded on an island would not resemble Peter Pan’s paradisiac Never Never Land, but would descend immediately into violence and terror more akin to William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies where the strongest ruled the weakest with merciless spite.”
      We have real life versions of that all the time! Nazi’s & Jew’s ring a bell? How about Saddam, Uday & Qusay Hussein and the horrors of torture and terror in Iraq. On and on add infinitum ad nauseam.
      Furthurmore, where does “Mistake” in the “The Worst Mistake In The History Of The Human Race” come from in your godless universe? There just “IS.”
      Atheism plagerizing morality from Christianity.

      • War is just organized violence, is it not? Why the hairsplitting over terms, when you’re referencing Nazis?

        And, I’m not an atheist. I’m not sure how you conjured that bullshit. I’m of Mennonite background, reference a Mennonite theologian on how I view the Bible….aaaaand you spout off “atheist.” Yay.

        If you can get past third grade name calling, feel free to respond.