Review of “Are You the One Who is to Come?”

Review of “Are You the One Who is to Come?” February 7, 2014

All of my books have a special place in my life and memory, but my volume Are You the One Who is to Come? The Historical Jesus and the Messianic Question is among my favourites. It feels kind of like my Habiltation and I think I made a solid scholarly case for Jesus as a messianic claimant. Sadly, though it seems to be largely ignored in most studies on messiahship that I’ve read over in the last couple of years (sigh!).

Anyway, glad to see a review of it up at Reading Acts by Philip Long.

He concludes:

This book appeared while I was working on my dissertation on the messianic banquet, so I quickly read through the book looking for material that I could use in that project. Much of the material in the first few chapters was familiar since I was working through similar issues. When I was asked to review the book as a part of the Logos Library I was able to re-read the book more slowly in order to catch the overall flow of the book. The book would make an excellent college or seminary textbook in a Gospels class since it does an excellent job describing the variety of messianic expectations in the Second Temple Period. It is not overly technical, although some of the details from the Dead Sea Scrolls might be overwhelming to some readers.  The footnotes provide a rich bibliography for readers who desire to dig deeper into messianic expectations in the Second Temple Period.

"Yes he certainly seems to overlook passages like Mathew 25:41 & Jude 7 "eternal fire", ..."

Revelation, Lake of Fire, Judgement of ..."
"Let's put your thesis on a firm basis; adduce the irrefutable, falsifiable, evidence for the ..."

Paula Fredriksen, the Early Church, and ..."
"It is an interesting epistemological principle that you are using. If the story contains miracles ..."

Paula Fredriksen, the Early Church, and ..."
"All sorts of weird things happen in faerie tales, no matter how incongruous or contradictory ..."

Paula Fredriksen, the Early Church, and ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Michael Barber

    I love that book. Use it as a textbook with grad students. Nice to see it getting some attention.

  • Paul Owen

    In case you missed it, I reviewed this book in JETS a few years back. An excellent volume, which makes a great contribution to the topic, though I differed with your approach at points.