An open letter to the webmaster (or why out-of-context quotes are bad)

An open letter to the webmaster (or why out-of-context quotes are bad) September 30, 2005

“Happiness and spiritual progress lie in following the leaders of the Church.”
—Elder Dallin H. Oaks
Ensign, May 1999, 37

I love the church, the gospel, and the prophets. I am a particularly big fan of Elder Oaks. But this quote, found without context on the page, is kinda creepy, huh.

Let’s put it in context. It is from a talk about Martin Harris. In it, Elder Oaks describes Harris’s life, emphasizing the good about him. He covers his alienation from and then reconciliation with the church. After covering the events of Harris’s life and his unwavering testimony of the Book of Mormon, Elder Oaks draws the following conclusions.

What do we learn from this example? (1) Witnesses are important, and the testimony of the Three Witnesses to the Book of Mormon is impressive and reliable. (2) Happiness and spiritual progress lie in following the leaders of the Church. (3) There is hope for each of us, even if we have sinned and strayed from a favored position.

In this context, the quote is much less creepy. It is inspiring even. It’s meaning is more fully informed. It is no longer a vaguely brainwashy message from on high, but rather an example of how the gospel ultimately blessed the life of a great man, an example we can learn from.

The church is in the habit of putting quotes up at its website, generally drawn from the General Conference talks of the quorum of the Twelve and the First Presidency. In general, I think it is a good idea, but they should try to remember that context helps one to understand the intended meaning. It allows us to grasp the whole picture a little better. So, dear webmaster of the site, please stop using a random generator for the quotes we see there. Read them over carefully and decide if the acontextual message you send out is one that we really want to say. From your neighbor, the Mormon.

"It's sad, yet predictable, to see how self-assured you critics can be despite your particular ..."

The Gaskill hoax, three years later
"Can someone clarify what was on this video?"

4 Puds With a Prooftext
"What a mean-spirited review. I've been reading Barker for a couple of months only. But ..."

My Margaret Barker Experience
"Thanks Todd Larkin and Greg M for the keen insight. I too believe the “TYD” ..."

Child Sacrifice, A Traditional Religious Practice ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Anonymous

    If you were a True Believer, John C.,  then you wouldn’t find that quote creepy. You would probably also not improperly use “It’s” in the next to the last paragraph. (I just gave myself away, didn’t I?)Really, though, even out of context, the quote is not all that bad, depending on how you interpret it. If you replaced “leaders of the Church” with Prophet(s), would that make it better? Posted by SheepOfTheFold

  • So, riddle me this: why do you find the original quote creepy?Is it because it’s a church leader saying you should follow the leaders?Do you find it sort of, oh, Heaven’s Gate or something?OneSheepForOneBrick