Profiles in Cowardice: Moving forward after the impeachment trial

Profiles in Cowardice: Moving forward after the impeachment trial February 4, 2020

Unless a miracle occurs, the impeachment trial of Donald John Trump will end today, with a vote strictly along party lines declining to remove the already-impeached President. All of this, of course, without any additional relevant witnesses or documents, even though the person who might perhaps be the most relevant witness of all is virtually pounding on the closed doors of the Senate chamber, waiting to be invited in to testify. It will be the political version of the final lines from T. S. Eliot’s poem “The Hollow Men”:

This is the way the world ends

This is the way the world ends

This is the way the world ends

Not with a bang but with a whimper.

Maybe there will unexpectedly by at least one Republican Senator today who will surprise everyone by voting “guilty,” just as Senator John McCain memorably gave a thumbs down in the wee hours of the morning a few years ago to defeat a Republican health care plan and preserve Obamacare for at least a while longer. But I doubt it. And it would take twenty or more Republicans with some courage to find the President guilty. I’m not holding my breath.

A year-and-a-half ago, while the President of the United States tweeted his usual string of petty Saturday morning inanities and irrelevancies, then went to play golf, millions of Americans spent some hours watching the memorial service for John McCain from the National Cathedral in Washington D.C. (to which the President was not invited). I was one of those millions of Americans, alternating between tears and laughter as a true American hero was remembered and celebrated. A few themes were present that we would do well to carry into the coming days, weeks, and months.

Before the service, MSNBC contributor Steve Schmidt, who was the day-to-day operations manager of McCain’s 2008 Presidential campaign, spoke of McCain’s displeasure and impatience with our current polarized political landscape, something that Schmidt called “A Season of Cowardice.” I’m sure that, today, Schmidt would say that this “season” has gotten worse, not better. At the memorial service, former President Obama described our present situation as one dominated by “manufactured outrage . . . rooted in fear.” That has only gotten worse over the past year-and-a-half. During the days between John McCain’s death and funeral, several people said that “we shall not see the likes of him again.”

But woven throughout the eulogies and testimonials was a common thread that all of us need to remember and commit ourselves to as we seek to use Senator McCain’s passing as more than just a brief respite before returning to business as usual. We need to remember, as Joe Lieberman reminded us in his eulogy, that “there is a special joy in serving something other than yourself.” That this observation sounds new and out of the box is a testament to just how far we have wandered from our country’s ideals, hopes, and dreams. Service to others, recognizing that none of us are self-sufficient, and the fundamental belief that some things are bigger than any of us are basic features of the American ethos. Over and over again, speakers at the memorial service described John McCain as having spent his life committed to country, family, friends, and faith rather than his own personal success. As his daughter Meghan powerfully explained, John McCain was defined by love: of his family, his country, and his God. When described that way, it sounds deceptively simple, but of such love are heroes made.

Shakespeare’s phrase from Hamlet—“we shall not see the likes of him again”—is a moving tribute. But something tells me that John McCain would not want to be described or remembered that way. McCain’s commitment to honor, decency, country, and public service was remarkable and he was a true American hero. But there was nothing in John McCain that is not available to each of us. Each of us is capable of honor, decency, humility, and service to others.

Despite the current political support and commitment of millions of my fellow Christians to an agenda and a person who exemplify none of these, the qualities that made John McCain great should not be a mystery to any person of faith. The life of faith is defined by a commitment to something greater than myself, accompanied by a desire and a dedication to understanding what that means in a human life on a daily basis.

Given the negative energies of our polarized country, we would do well to ask ourselves regularly what things we should commit to that are greater than ourselves. What things are worth dying for? We still have the courageously lived and eloquently honored life of John McCain fresh in our memories, a life that can serve as an inspiration for us to become better than we currently are. Let’s not waste it.


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment