Muslims kill Muslims, for no reasons that can be reported

Muslims kill Muslims, for no reasons that can be reported August 14, 2013

The bloodshed in Egypt continues and, to be quite frank about it, it’s hard to know what to write about most of the mainstream news coverage. This is especially true if your primary goal is to understand the role that religion is playing in these hellish events.

Through it all, I have been asking the following question:

Is it possible, in a land in which the majority of voters hunger for Islamic law, to defend the rights of religious minorities and secular liberals without the help of a military that is willing to oppress and jail Islamists?

In other words, most Egyptians want some kind of Islamic state — while the military leaders desire to keep leading a state that offers a more secular approach to Islam. In the coverage you are reading, notice how often the Muslim Brotherhood leaders proclaim that they are trying to prevent Egypt from turning into Syria? What is wrong with Syria, in the view of Islamists?

Meanwhile, a tragic equation is returning to Egyptian life, one that is seen in every generation.

Bluntly stated, that equation goes something like this: Military police attack Islamists, which inspires renewed Islamist attacks on churches and other symbols of religious minority life — safe and familiar scapegoats.

You see, the key fighting is between two large Muslim camps — the Islamists and the old guard in the military. In most Western media reports this is called “sectarian violence” or some variation on this term. This is something like saying that the black churches that burned during the U.S. civil rights era burned because of “sectarian violence.”

See, for example, the top of a new Los Angeles Times report:

CAIRO — Deadly clashes and sectarian tensions spread across Egypt on Wednesday after security forces stormed two Cairo sit-ins, killing scores of supporters of deposed Islamist President Mohamed Morsi.

The interim government declared a state of emergency as battles between Morsi loyalists and police erupted in Cairo, Alexandria, Aswan and in smaller towns and villages. Public buildings were set ablaze and Egyptian media reported churches were attacked in a number of provinces as Islamists blamed Christians for backing the army.

The government, appointed last month after a coup overthrew Morsi and his Muslim Brotherhood movement, accused Islamists of instigating bloodshed by shooting at police. The Brotherhood said police fired live ammunition at peaceful protesters, who fled in panic down streets and alleys engulfed in tear gas and scattered with bullet casings.

Why attack churches if the enemy is the secular military?

Might this have something to do with many police officers and soldiers being afraid of the spiritual, personal consequences of being seen defending the lives and holy sites of infidels? After all, churches burned under the old military regime, too.

For me, I continue to search for news coverage that actually describes the policy differences between the Islamists and the Muslims who control the military. What do the Islamists want, in practical terms? What do the military Muslims fear, in practical terms?

And, as a human-rights concern, I urge readers to keep looking for new information about the safety of Jews, minority Muslims, Protestants, Orthodox Copts, etc. Are you seeing that information reported?

Instead, we keep seeing the same code phrases:

Millions of Egyptians had also called for a crackdown on the Brotherhood. Much of the country has rallied behind Gen. Abdel Fattah Sisi, commander of the armed forces, who led the military coup against Morsi. The new, largely secular government blamed the former president for attempting to tilt the country toward Islamic law.

“I swear by God that if you stay in your homes, Abdel Fattah Sisi will embroil this country so that it becomes Syria,” said Mohamed El-Beltagy, a Brotherhood leader, whose daughter was killed in the violence. “Abdel Fattah Sisi will push this nation to a civil war so that he escapes the gallows.”

There it is again. What does “tilt the country toward Islamic law” mean? Why are thousands willing to die to defend that vision? My are Egyptian Muslims willing to kill other Egyptian Muslims in order to prevent that from taking place?

A few basic facts, please.

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

6 responses to “Muslims kill Muslims, for no reasons that can be reported”

  1. I’ve said this before: most reporters in this country can hardly understand the differences between the common religious groups and categories here (e.g. Roman Catholics and Episcopalians). Reporters here seem to go out of their way to avoid talking about religion in America. Why do we expect them to do either, let alone do it well, in the complex religious setting of the Middle East?

    Further, I believe that most reporters in America beleve that most readers don’t care about what’s happening in Egypt. I recently had a reporter from the local NBC affilliate tell me that most watchers don’t even know where Egypt is, let alone care what happens there. I’m afraid that she is right.

    The solution, though, is for all the msm (print, radio, television, and web) to do the best possible job of reporting. That’s why the work of this blog is so important. It should be required reading for all journalists daily. I say we make it part of j-school curriculum, too. Make ’em all take a test on Monday to see if they retain any of it from the week before! If they fail they don’t get paid til they pass a re-test. (By the way, is there a GetPolitics?)

  2. Whatever the disturbance, and no matter which side is in ascendance, the Christians are fair game for destruction. Our government may take sides among the non-Christians, but oddly (?) doesn’t notice the damage done to a faith which was present 600 years before the Islamists existed in any of the Middle Eastern countries.

  3. The press is as blind and deaf as the government, apparently.
    [When Clinton was in Myanmar (Burma) she worried about Buddhists attacking Muslims. Never mind that Christians on the Thai border have been under attack by the Burmese military for 40+ years.]

  4. Can you point to any good articles on this topic? I received a newsletter (from Coptic Orphans) saying 400 Christian churches were torched on the 14th – but it seems every news article has a low (and different) number.