So there: Rod Dreher goes and writes a GetReligion post

So there: Rod Dreher goes and writes a GetReligion post February 26, 2014

So, yes, I’ll admit that I was a bit disappointed (stage cue: slight choke in voice) to find out — while reading Rod “friend of this blog” Dreher’s usual 10,000 to 15,000 words of daily blogging output — that I was not one of the two newspaper columnists that he consistently gets to read. But, hey, I run in small- and mid-sized newspapers and I know that Rod’s a very busy guy. I mean, really, look at his blog: He must read 10 books and journals a day!

So, what really interested me was that, right in the middle of that particular post (a meditation on whether news columnists still matter during these online-commentary-saturated days), the working boy went and produced a genuine chunk of fantastic GetReligion work.

So without further ado, I hereby claim said chunk of type as a guest column.

So there.

You probably have examples in mind from your own experience of ways that current newspaper columnists could make their work more inspired, and therefore inspiring. I’d like to hear them. Whether you and I, readers, are coming from the left or the right or somewhere in between, I think we can agree that the uniformity of consensus opinion in our newspapers and on TV is a big part of the problem. And it’s not only uniformity of opinion about the left-right boundaries of our discourse. It’s a uniformity of opinion about what constitutes news.

Let’s take Fox News for example. This is supposed to be the conservative news network, but their idea of what constitutes conservatism, and news of interest to conservative viewers, is deeply Washington-centric, and deeply centered in the media class and its prejudices. In this, they’re no different from the competition; it’s just that as someone who has been part of the conservosphere for most of my adult life, it frustrates me to see how much Fox is ignoring for the sake of observing media conventions. For example, I’ve long marveled over the lack of religion and culture coverage on Fox. By religion and culture, I don’t mean the “War On Christmas” and other tabloid staples. I mean any sort of serious, sustained coverage, both in reporting and commentary, of stories emerging out of the world of religion and culture — stories that tell us, for better and for worse, something important about the world we’re in.

Here’s an example. In my little Southern town, the Methodist church is about to get a new minister — a woman pastor. She follows a woman pastor, who broke the clergy gender line at the church. My folks, who attend there, gave me the news the other night, and I mentioned to them that they will probably not live to see another male pastor at that parish. I explained to them that this is partly because of their age, but also because in mainline Protestant churches, the clergy class is becoming more and more female. Women make up about 20 percent of the clergy in mainline Protestant denominations, including Methodism — but that is fast changing. According to a 2006 New York Times report:

Women now make up 51 percent of the students in divinity school. But in the mainline Protestant churches that have been ordaining women for decades, women account for only a small percentage — about 3 percent, according to one survey by a professor at Duke University — of pastors who lead large congregations, those with average Sunday attendance over 350. In evangelical churches, most of which do not ordain women, some women opt to leave for other denominations that will accept them as ministers. Women from historically black churches who want to ascend to the pulpit often start their own congregations.

It’s clear that what’s going on at the local Methodist church reflects a national shift in the culture of Protestantism. How are congregations receiving this? How is the increasing feminization changing clerical life, and the lives of their congregations? Are churches that accept women pastors thriving by comparison to those that don’t? Why or why not? None of these questions are new to people on the left and the right who follow trends in American religion, but they were new to my mom and dad, who are ordinary people (and big Fox News watchers) whose experience of religion is whatever happens at their own church. They really didn’t know about what’s been going on in Methodism and in mainline Protestantism — the broader trends, I mean.

This is a big story! When a conservative town in the Deep South gets its second female Methodist minister, something’s going on. You might call it progress, you might call it decline, but Attention Must Be Paid.

This kind of story is such a rich source of insight into how our country is changing, but it’s not the kind of story you are likely to see in our national media, unless, say, the female minister came out of the closet, and her congregation revolted — in which case the story could be folded into the gay-rights narrative that obsesses our national media today. An ordinary female pastor with a husband and kids taking up the pulpit in an ordinary Southern river town, and everybody accepting it — that is a more socially revolutionary thing than a lesbian pastor running afoul of her congregation. But it’s not the kind of thing that most people in the national media are going to care much about, because they don’t patrol these waters, looking for stories.

So, GetReligion readers, what are some of the major, behind-the-scenes religion-based stories — either (a) in your religious flocks or (b) in your zip codes or (c) both — that you believe the mainstream media are missing?

Remember that old saying here at GetReligion (one of several we pull out from time to time): If journalists want to cover real news events and trends in the lives of real people living in the real world, then they will have to start taking religion seriously.

So what’s going on out there? Share.

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment

3 responses to “So there: Rod Dreher goes and writes a GetReligion post”

  1. I would say the MSM is missing out on the rise of the Traditional Catholic parishes staffed by the FSSP. and part of this story is that young people are joining these parishes

  2. Perhaps once every few years the local daily will stop to take note of the fact that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints somehow manages to exist here in the Buckle of the Bible Belt.

    …and in the process, completely miss the astounding local growth rates, which by all rights shouldn’t be happening due to how staunchly Protestant (particularly Southern Baptist and non-denominational Protestant) the area is.

    In fact, a few years ago we had to split the stake (re: diocese) in half because so many new congregations had been formed and so many people were joining the old congregations that it got to be a logistical nightmare trying to get everyone together for important meetings and joint youth activities.

    Makes you wonder how they could miss the fact that a religion that a lot of locals still regard as a “cult” could make such great in-roads despite the given opposition.

  3. I’d like to see mainstream reporters take interest in the ways theologically orthodox, conservative, or “evangelical” young people are practicing their faith in culturally subversive ways. Anecdotally I’m seeing more of this among young Christians in my area.

    In the religious press there have been stories about the growing interest in “new monastic” lifestyles or “intentional communities” or “communal living” or other faith-based practices that deliberately challenge the self-centered, consumeristic, licentious, and media-driven dominant culture of America. And sometimes this countercultural approach is nothing more than some of the redneck good ol’ boys and girls who are choosing to hang on to (or rediscover) their religious roots with an emphasis on hard work, faith, and devotion to family (as in — being a good husband and father). But I’ve yet to see the mainstream media take notice of any of these trends.

    Glowing puff pieces on Nadia Bolz-Weber don’t count.

Close Ad